No Design · The chapters

Afterword: A Few Last Wonders

By the How To Muslim team

Before we part, a few more wonders. The arguments can wait a page or two.

Start with a bird you could cup in one hand. It goes by two names, the Pacific parrotlet and the celestial parrotlet, and the second is the more accurate. Nearly all of it is green, the green of the sky's edge at daybreak. On the male, though, a band of colour sweeps over the wings and down the rump, cobalt at its deepest and paling to soft lavender, as if someone had trimmed a strip from the evening and sewn it on.

Here is the surprise. There is no blue paint in that feather. Birds have almost no blue pigment, so nearly every blue bird you have admired was, strictly speaking, performing a trick of optics. Open a single barb and you find a sponge of keratin riddled with tiny air pockets. Their spacing is fine enough that the light scattered back interferes with itself: most colours cancel, and blue comes back out to meet your eye. Beneath the sponge, a layer of dark pigment drinks up whatever light gets through, so nothing rises from below to dilute the blue. Painters know this recipe, a scattering layer over a black ground. The parrotlet works it at a scale finer than the wavelengths it is sorting, with the same physics that colours the chameleon's skin in Chapter 3, the peacock spider's fan in Chapter 7 and the sheen on a butterfly's wing.

And the blue has a day job. In this species it is largely the male's, which is why males and females are coloured differently, and he puts it to work when he courts.

Yet the courtship story stops short of the most interesting part. A signal only needs to be dependable, and a reliable patch of dull brown would announce a healthy male just as clearly. By the cold arithmetic of signalling, beige would have done fine. Then there is us. You and I will never court a parrotlet, and still we catch sight of that blue and something in us rises to meet it. Whatever the colour does for the bird, it does something else entirely for the person watching, and the bird's mating system has nothing to say about that. Beauty spills over the brim of function here, and on the receiving end stands a creature made to notice the overflow and enjoy it.

We have met that pairing before. A mind far larger than survival ever asked for, in Chapter 3. A universe we can do physics on. A sky clear enough to study, in Chapter 4. Mathematics we can read, in Chapter 11. And now a colour we can love. Each time something is provided beyond what the situation requires, and each time someone is on hand to receive it.

Next, the Picasso moth, Baorisa hieroglyphica, scarce and lovely, found from northern India across Southeast Asia. Whoever named it was not exaggerating. Its wings look arranged in the gallery sense of the word: strokes of line, blocks of colour and little figures like hieroglyphs, placed so deliberately that you would swear a brush had been involved.

Markings like these earn their keep. They can warn a predator off or break up the outline a hunter is scanning for, and this moth may well put its pattern to just that use. A job description, though, rarely asks for brushwork. Whatever the pattern does, it had no need to be laid out like a painting to do it.

Then there are the hummingbird flowers. Some blossoms have grown long, narrow and tubular, very often red, matched to a bird that hovers and probes with a needle of a beak, while the bird is built to reach nectar most visitors cannot touch. The partnership has to balance its books. A hovering hummingbird spends energy faster than almost any other animal with a backbone; mitochondria fill about a third of its flight muscle, where yours manage a few percent. The flower has to make every trip pay.

Flower and bird answer each other so snugly they look like two halves drawn on one sheet of paper. The guest list stays open: other creatures sip at these flowers, and the hummingbirds work their way through many kinds of bloom. What holds you is the exactness of the match, each side shaped to the other and each paid in the other's currency.

Last, picture the owl on the wing. Wide spread, not a whisper, each feather shaped for silence in the ways Chapter 1 set out. Stop the frame there and the engineering falls away, leaving something simpler. Majesty. The owl has no idea it looks like that. It just does.

And that, more than anything, is what stays with me. None of these creatures has to know it is beautiful for the beauty to be real. It looks, for all the world, as though it was meant for the one doing the looking.

Debts

Three of those wonders reached me as other people's pictures before they became my paragraphs. Nick Stacey and Rajesh Kumar Photography put the parrotlet and the Picasso moth in front of me; Steve Woods Photography gave me the owl. Much of the spark for this closing, and for the whole book, came from the @freemonotheist account, which lays out the evidence of design in nature with a visual punch that leaves a writer trotting along behind with his sentences.

That account is also where I first ran into the hashtag #NoDesign. Its job was dismissal: two words standing in for the claim that the design we think we see is an illusion. The longer I scrolled, the more those two words seemed to be arguing the other side.

No design? Look again.

That question grew into this book.

What medicine taught me

My love of the natural world goes back to childhood: wandering garden paths, craning my neck at the canopy, sensing that everything alive was gesturing toward something beyond itself. You do not need a laboratory to read those signs. The flower outside your window carries them. So does a spider's web strung with dew, and so, for that matter, does the hand holding this page.

Years ago I took up medicine, and the human body seen up close gave that childhood wonder somewhere new to go.

Give the circulation an afternoon and it will floor you. Set its vessels end to end and they would run ten to twenty thousand kilometres (Chapter 9 has the sums), millions of times the height of the person they live in. The heart keeps up roughly a hundred thousand beats a day, and not one of them waits for your say-so. My favourite detail is a quieter one. The vessels can feel the blood going by. The cells that line them register the drag of the passing current and answer with a chemical message, nitric oxide, which loosens the surrounding muscle so that a vessel opens up wherever the flow runs high. These are pipes that re-gauge themselves, day and night, to suit whatever runs through them. I have yet to meet a plumber who offers that.

The immune system goes further. It answers a problem that sounds impossible. Your body must be ready for germs that do not exist yet, some of which will appear decades after you were born. Picture sitting an exam whose questions nobody has written. Keeping a ready-made antibody for every possibility is out, since some twenty thousand genes leave nowhere near enough room for the billions required. So the body takes a cleverer route. It keeps the relevant genes in pieces and, inside each developing cell, physically cuts and splices them into new combinations, building a vast library of receptors by mixing rather than storing. When one receptor happens to latch onto a real invader, the body deliberately mutates that gene at a million times the usual rate and keeps whichever versions grip better. It invents its own variety to face threats it cannot predict, then hones the answer once the question finally turns up.

Look closely at that second step. It is mutation and selection, the very engine a design argument is supposed to fear. The body shows no fear at all. It switches the engine on inside small structures in the lymph nodes, points it at one short stretch of one gene, lets it run for a few days while the infection is live, and then shuts it down. A good surgeon treats a scalpel the same way: briefly, exactly, and never left lying about. Random variation here is an instrument, used in the single place where variation pays and held in check everywhere else. Arranging that is harder than mutating everything, and harder than mutating nothing.

An evolutionary biologist might answer that the narrowing evolved as well, with selection reining in a mutator that once fired indiscriminately. It may have. Notice, though, what that answer has already accepted: that random variation left to itself does damage, that its value depends wholly on being aimed, and that something had to aim it. The question has moved from whether aim was needed to what supplied it, a narrower dispute than the usual one and a far more interesting one. And once we are discussing aim, we are already speaking the language of design.

Over and over I felt gratitude rising in me. Medicine taught me that a doctor does not really cure anybody. We help the body do what it already knows how to do; the healing is its own, and mostly we hold the door. It keeps itself in repair, too, and every second, in a thousand quiet ways, holds life together against the downhill slide of entropy.

The balcony

Some of the deepest moments came without an invitation.

One evening I was out on a balcony with nothing to do but watch. The sun was going down, laying colours across the sky that the parrotlet itself might covet, and beneath me life went on keeping a time far older than mine.

It came to me that the fish in the rivers are looked after. They live inside a web of relationships balanced so finely that pulling out one species sends trouble rippling down the whole chain. The birds are looked after, finding food and cover in a countryside that never stops changing and yet somehow never runs short. The sheep in the field are looked after: grass beneath them, rain above, the flock grazing and the grass coming back, year after year, so dependably that we notice the arrangement only when it falters.

We are looked after too, we who were placed here to tend the earth. Fish from waters that would drown us within minutes. Minerals hauled from the darkness of caves. Birds and eggs from the open air. From the fields, grain and fruit and vegetables in a dizzying spread of colours, flavours and nourishment. No one place supplies it all. Between them, they supply plenty.

Standing there, one word reached my lips before I had decided to say it. SubhanAllah. Glory be to God.

More than complexity

Some of you have carried an objection for several chapters now, so let me meet it head on. Plenty of arguments, it goes, and not one of them proves God. All you have shown me is complexity.

On complexity alone, you would be right. A snowflake is fantastically intricate, and nobody pictures a workshop of craftsmen cutting each one by hand. Complexity on its own tells you a system has many parts, and nothing about how they arrived.

Complexity was never what I was pointing at, though. The thing I have kept coming back to, chapter by chapter, is what William Dembski calls specified complexity, and the gap between those two ideas is where everything happens.

Take the snowflake first. It has complexity and no specification. However lovely it is, it carries no message and performs no job, and its shape comes straight from the way water molecules bond, which is why Chapter 11 could account for its hexagons without any designer at all.

DNA is complex in an entirely different sense. As Chapter 5 showed, chemistry does not dictate the order of its sequence, and that freedom is exactly what lets the sequence carry information. That information also has somewhere to go. It builds proteins; the proteins fold into machines; the machines run cells; the cells make up organisms that live and reproduce. Here is complexity with a target, complexity that does a day's work and carries instructions.

Think of that one word, specified, as a sieve. Pour the natural world through it and the hexagon in ice slips straight past. What stays caught in the mesh is a butterfly with a migration route written into it. That one still has some explaining to do.

Many witnesses, one verdict

Pull any one chapter out and you can quarrel with it. A sceptic can answer fine-tuning with a shrug and a multiverse, put the information in DNA in a drawer labelled "not yet explained," and hand the molecular machines to some gradual pathway still waiting to be found. But the chapters were never built to stand alone. Philosophers call what they make together a cumulative case: independent lines of evidence that all arrive at the same place.

In the Introduction I asked you to read like a juror, and here is where that pays off. One witness can be cross-examined into a shrug. A whole row of witnesses who have never met, from fields that owe one another nothing, all describing the same thing, is far harder to wave away.

And the same patterns kept turning up. Arbitrary signals that work only because sender and receiver share a convention: the dolphin's signature whistle in Chapter 3, DNA in Chapter 5, the waggle dance in Chapter 7. Settings calibrated right up against the limits of physics: the camel in Chapter 3, two utterly different particles whose charges match to twenty decimal places in Chapter 5, the cochlea in Chapter 9. Our engineers arriving second at the bird's wing, the chameleon's crystals, the gecko's foot and the humpback's flipper, with nature holding the prior art every time. Verdicts of "bad design" coming apart on closer study: the polar bear, the inverted retina, the box jellyfish's blurred eye, the capacity for pain. And predictions that came true: Hoyle's carbon resonance in Chapter 4, Dirac's positron in Chapter 5.

Tug on any single thread and it may give a little. Tug on all of them together and you find they are tied off at the same place.

The best explanation

A theorem gets a proof. A valley gets an inference, and so does a patient, and the case I have made is of that second kind, built from what we observe. It needs no grand closing sum that scores design against chance and announces near-certainty, since the odds in a sum like that are picked rather than derived, and a method that can be tuned to produce certainty can be tuned to produce anything.

Here is my claim. Take everything we actually observe, from the reach of the cosmos to the inner workings of a single cell to the quiet astonishment of a sunset from a balcony, and ask what explains the whole of it best. My answer is a Creator. That is an inference to the best explanation, and I hold it with exactly the confidence such an inference earns.

Inference to the best explanation is no soft option. It is how most of what we know gets known. Charles Peirce gave it a name, abduction, and philosophers have been sharpening it ever since. A geologist looking at scratched rock, scattered deposits and the telltale shape of a valley's walls says "glacier" without waiting for a proof, because no rival handles all of it as well. Medicine, my own trade, runs on the same move. No diagnosis is ever proved. A patient brings a handful of signs; we look for the one account that explains them all, commit to it, and stay ready to drop it the moment a new sign refuses to fit. Confident enough to act, open enough to revise: that is all I am asking of you here.

The rival view often bills itself as the one travelling without luggage. Unzip the bags. Packed on top is specified complexity with nobody doing the specifying. Under it, the constants of nature, settled into the thin band that lets life exist, by luck. Then a code in every cell that composed itself, though not once have we watched information appear without a mind behind it. And folded at the bottom, the first living thing, coaxed out of non-life along a route that decades of hard work have left a hypothesis. That is a lot of luggage for someone travelling light.

Thoughtful, sincere people hold that view in good faith. Faith, it turns out, sits on both sides of the table. Both readings travel with commitments. Weigh the bags against what we see when we actually look, and the one marked "chance" turns out to be the heavier.

Look again

So look, and here is what you find. A little green bird carrying a strip of sky, its colour engineered at a scale finer than light. A moth whose wings could hang in a gallery. A flower and a bird cut to each other's measure. An owl wearing a majesty it will never know about.

A body that patches its own wounds and trains for invaders before they ever arrive. A world that sets the table from every direction at once, from river and cave and open sky and field. A universe whose numbers sit on a knife-edge, and here we are because they do.

And, for anyone with eyes for it, the signature of the One who made it all. The Quran sets creation before us in exactly this way: as signs to reflect on, an invitation rather than a textbook. The signs are within us and around us, and they ask something of us: to know Him, to remember Him, and at last to answer the thing that has been whispering to us since before we had the words.

"Will they not, then, reflect?"

References

  • Pacific (celestial) parrotlet, Forpus coelestis — blue coloration is structural, produced by coherent light scattering from a spongy keratin-and-air nanostructure in the feather barbs rather than by pigment; a melanin layer beneath the nanostructure absorbs transmitted light, without which the blue is washed out. The blue is chiefly a male trait and functions in mate choice.
  • Picasso moth, Baorisa hieroglyphica — northern India and Southeast Asia. Wing patterns of this kind can serve aposematic (warning) or disruptive (outline-breaking) roles.
  • Hummingbird–flower coadaptation — ornithophilous flowers also receive other visitors, and hummingbirds feed at many blooms. Hovering flight has among the highest mass-specific metabolic rates of any vertebrate; flight-muscle mitochondrial volume density is ~35% (Suarez et al., 1991, PNAS 88).
  • Owl silent flight — see Chapter 1 (leading-edge serrations, velvet surface, trailing-edge fringe).
  • Cardiovascular figures — as established in Chapter 9. Endothelial shear-stress sensing with nitric-oxide-mediated vasodilation, so that vessels adjust their diameter in response to flow: Furchgott & Zawadzki (1980, Nature 288); nitric oxide as the signalling molecule, Nobel Prize 1998 (Furchgott, Ignarro, Murad).
  • Adaptive immunity, V(D)J recombination — receptor diversity generated combinatorially by cutting and rejoining gene segments (RAG-1/RAG-2), then refined by somatic hypermutation (AID) at rates ~10⁶ above background, with selection for higher affinity. The system generates its own diversity against antigens not yet encountered.
  • Somatic hypermutation confinement — Victora & Nussenzweig (2022, Annu. Rev. Immunol. 40): confined to germinal centres, to the immunoglobulin variable region, and to the duration of an active response; mutation and selection deployed as a regulated tool rather than as a general condition.
  • Dembski, W. — specified complexity and the design inference.
  • Abduction — Peirce (1878); Lipton, Inference to the Best Explanation (2004). Inference to the best explanation as a form of reasoning, illustrated by diagnostic and geological inference.
  • Photo and inspiration credits — Nick Stacey; Rajesh Kumar Photography; Steve Woods Photography; the @freemonotheist account; the #NoDesign hashtag.

Download the whole book (free PDF)