No Design · The chapters

Chapter 2: Signs in the Green

By the How To Muslim team

"He is the One who sends down water from the sky, and with it We produce vegetation of all kinds." (Quran 6:99)

We drive past some of the most sophisticated machines on Earth every morning and call them the hedge. A plant stands still, makes no sound and asks for no attention, so it slips into the background with the lamp posts and the road signs. That modesty makes a superb disguise. Behind it runs a self-repairing chemistry we still cannot reproduce, and the whole living world leans on it.

Chapter 1 belonged to the birds, whose wings our engineers ended up copying a century late. The organisms in this chapter set a stiffer test. They cannot fly or walk, and wherever their seed landed, there they stay. Not one of them owns a brain. Every problem they meet, they solve with molecules, and between them they keep the planet running.

Take a breath. You have just sampled a mixture set with remarkable care. Oxygen makes up about a fifth of the air, 21 percent, and the margins on either side are narrower than you might guess. Combustion chemists have mapped them. Let the level sink much below about 15 percent and flames can no longer sustain themselves, while the big, busy, warm-bodied animals that burn their fuel fast would struggle to keep their engines turning. Let it climb much above 25 percent and the trouble flips: fire catches so eagerly that even wet vegetation burns, and one bolt of lightning could clear the forests of a continent. Complex life has to live between those two cliffs, with enough oxygen to power an animal and little enough to keep the living world from going up in smoke. That gap is exactly where our air sits.

Better still, the setting holds itself, and no lucky streak is involved. Fire does the regulating. When oxygen creeps upward, blazes ignite more readily and run further, forests burn back, fewer leaves remain to photosynthesise, less oxygen gets made, and the level drifts down. When oxygen sags, fires struggle to get going, growth piles up unburned, a greener world photosynthesises harder, and the level climbs again. Hazard and brake turn out to be the same thing. The danger of oxygen-rich air is precisely what keeps the air from getting rich.

What you have just read is a thermostat. We will meet another in Chapter 4, where the carbon cycle keeps Earth's temperature steady over billion-year stretches. Each breath you take comes from a regulated supply, held in the band life needs by a mechanism that pushes back whichever way it is nudged.

The history of that air is grander than the tidy tale of plants and animals arriving together to swap gases. Cyanobacteria were splitting water and releasing oxygen well over two billion years before the first animal drew breath, and all that while volcanoes and the young Earth kept carbon dioxide in generous supply. The marvel lies in the level at which oxygen finally settled, so exactly suited to complex life, and in the machine that makes it. That machine comes next.

Photosynthesis: the machine we cannot build

Watch photosynthesis closely and the word "reaction" stops fitting. Sunlight, water and carbon dioxide go into a leaf; sugar comes out, with oxygen released along the way, and in between runs an assembly line of parts that interlock. Chlorophyll gathers the photons. The thylakoid, a folded membrane system, holds each piece of equipment in its proper place relative to the rest. A chain of molecules hands the captured energy down the line, step by step, the way a bucket brigade passes water. ATP synthase, a genuine turbine only nanometres wide, spins as protons pour through it and converts that energy into the currency the cell spends. Last comes Rubisco, an enzyme believed to be the most abundant protein on the planet, which pulls carbon dioxide from the air and fixes it into the first sugar.

Linger on that motor a moment. ATP synthase spins at up to about a hundred full turns a second, the top speed measured in bacteria (the pace varies with organism and direction). That is a car engine at cruising speed, packed into a machine a few billionths of a metre across.

Pull out a single part and production stops. Light caught by chlorophyll with no electron chain to receive it simply goes to waste. Energy carried down an electron chain with no Rubisco at the end never turns into food. You cannot run half of this system and still feed the cell, and that is the snag for any slow, piece-by-piece assembly: none of the parts earns its place until all of them are there and correctly arranged. Every step has been described in fine detail, and laboratories can imitate fragments, splitting water here and fixing carbon there. After a century of effort, no chemist can assemble the whole working system from raw ingredients, or explain how it got itself started when each component is useless without the others. A solar panel starts life in mines and factories and calls for rare metals. A leaf asks for sunlight, water and air, and it repairs itself.

That closing phrase, it repairs itself, hides a small drama. The light a leaf lives on is also slowly wrecking it. Deep in Photosystem II sits a protein called D1, and the photons it is there to collect keep battering it to pieces. So in strong sunshine the leaf carries out running repairs in the most literal sense: about every half hour the damaged D1 comes out, gets dismantled, and a newly built copy is fitted in its place, while photosynthesis carries on around it. Ask a plant manager to replace a part that central at that pace without shutting the line down, and watch the reaction. The leaf never shuts down.

Botany's favourite exhibit against design is Rubisco. Measured the way enzymologists measure things, it is a poor worker. A typical enzyme handles thousands of reactions per second; Rubisco manages something in the range of three to ten. Worse, a substantial fraction of the time it seizes oxygen instead of carbon dioxide, setting off a wasteful side-reaction the plant must spend energy undoing. So the leaf makes it in absurd quantity, up to half its soluble protein, and the most common protein on Earth turns out to be a slow enzyme that often makes mistakes.

Two answers meet that charge. The first is that our verdicts of "badly built" have a poor record. The inverted retina we met in the Introduction, and the polar bear's fur we will meet in Chapter 3, both looked like blunders until the constraints came into view, and there is a real case that Rubisco belongs with them. The enzyme appears to sit on a trade-off, where gaining speed costs specificity and gaining specificity costs speed, so its apparent sloppiness may be close to the best compromise available. That research question is still open, and the second answer stands however it is settled.

Suppose Rubisco really is as clumsy as it looks. The case for design stands exactly where it was. Put a slow worker on an assembly line of chlorophyll, membranes, electron chains and a rotary motor and you still have an assembly line, and every station must be in place before any of them earns its keep. Nobody looks at a watch that loses time and concludes that no one made it. Second-rate design is design all the same, and the objection, followed to the end, leads straight back to the machine it set out to dismiss.

Flowers and bees: a conversation in static electricity

"And your Lord inspired the bee: Take for yourself among the mountains, houses, and among the trees and in that which they construct. Then eat from all the fruits and follow the ways of your Lord laid down. There emerges from their bellies a drink, varying in colours, in which there is healing for people. Indeed, in that is a sign for a people who give thought." (Quran 16:68–69)

Grasses and many trees trust their pollen to the wind, and plenty of flowers simply fertilise themselves. A great many others hire couriers. The deal is simple: the flower pays in nectar, and the insect, busy drinking, dusts itself with pollen and carries it to the next bloom. Both sides come away better off, and the partnership is tuned more finely than anyone suspected. One recent discovery is, quite literally, electric.

Here is how it works. Standing rooted in the earth, a flower usually holds a faint negative charge. A bee picks up a positive charge as its wings beat through the air. When the bee draws near, the imbalance is strong enough that pollen grains jump across the gap to its body before its feet ever touch the petals. That is no metaphor. In 2013 Dominic Clarke, Daniel Robert and their colleagues at the University of Bristol reported in Science that bumblebees can actually sense these floral electric fields. In 2016 Gregory Sutton's group found the sensor: fine, stiff hairs covering the bee's body, so light that a field too faint to stir the antennae sets them trembling. Bees learn to read the fields and use them to choose their flowers. Once a bee has emptied a bloom, the flower's charge shifts, and the new field hangs out a sign for the next visitor: someone has been here, try again later.

Consider what has been built here. Physics carries the message, and nobody involved has to think. Neither the bee nor the flower has ever studied electrostatics, and both are fluent in it. The system pays off only if several things line up together: the charge on the flower, the charge on the bee, pollen that responds to the field, and a bee able to read the change. Give a flower nectar without the charge, or give a bee a sense tuned to the wrong field, and nothing is gained. The fit between them is the wonder.

Underground: a trade between kingdoms

"And you see the earth barren, but when We send down upon it rain, it quivers and swells and grows something of every beautiful kind." (Quran 22:5)

Beneath the forest floor runs another partnership. You may have met the "Wood Wide Web", with mother trees nursing seedlings and warnings racing from trunk to trunk along fungal cables. When Justine Karst and colleagues reviewed the evidence in Nature Ecology and Evolution in 2023, they found those grander claims more asserted than demonstrated. The forest gossip outruns the evidence. The trade underneath it is real, and to my mind it is the greater wonder.

Most plants have roots woven together with mycorrhizal fungi, and the two run a genuine exchange. The fungal threads spread through the soil much further than any root could, gathering water and minerals the plant would struggle to get and passing them back. The plant pays in sugar made from sunlight, the one thing the fungus has no way of making on its own. Each side brings precisely what the other is missing. The plant runs the solar farm, the fungus runs the mines, and they settle up in sugar at the root tip. The arrangement is ancient and close to universal: about nine in ten land plants take part, and many of them cannot thrive without their fungus. Picture it plainly. Two living things from separate kingdoms, swapping perfectly complementary goods by means of a chemical handshake. A bargain matched that exactly sends your thoughts, unprompted, toward the One who arranged it.

Advertising, and a traffic light

"And We sent down rain from the sky and made grow thereby gardens of beauty and delight." (Quran 50:7)

Then there are the colours of flowers, and every one of them is a signal. Pigments paint the petals red, yellow and blue. Past the edge of human vision, many blooms also wear ultraviolet markings that an insect sees as clearly as we see print: dark bands and bullseyes leading a bee in to the nectar, much as the lights along a runway bring a pilot down. A flower we would call plain white may look, to a bee, like a target with rings and arrows pointing to the middle. Each colour scheme is aimed at a particular viewer. Reds pull in hummingbirds. Bees answer to blues and yellows and to ultraviolet marks meant for their eyes alone. Every flower is an advertisement composed for the senses of the creature it needs to reach.

A few plants go further and revise their advertising as things change. The horse chestnut shows how. While a blossom is unpollinated and still has nectar to give, its centre bears a yellow spot. After a visit and fertilisation, the spot shifts to pink and then to red. Red is hard for bees to see, so the finished flowers drop out of their attention and they work the yellow-spotted ones that still pay. In this way the tree directs its pollinators to the blooms still waiting and away from the ones already served, and neither bee nor tree wastes effort. An organism without eyes, brain or nerves is running traffic lights, changing the signal on each flower as the weeks go by.

Seeds: how a thing that cannot move sends its children away

"It is He who has spread out the earth and placed therein firmly set mountains and rivers, and of all fruits He has made two mates; He causes the night to cover the day. Indeed, in that are signs for a people who give thought." (Quran 13:3)

A rooted organism has a problem with its offspring: it cannot carry them anywhere. Plants answer with small masterpieces of engineering, each suited to a particular route. The dandelion slings every seed under a feathery parachute, balanced so finely that a breeze lifts it well away from the parent without simply carrying it out to sea. That parachute flies by a method nobody had guessed. In 2018 a team led by Cathal Cummins showed in Nature that the bristles do much more than catch air like a cloth canopy. Air passing between them sets up a small, steady ring of swirling air that floats free in the space above the seed, a kind of structure fluid dynamicists had never recorded. This detached vortex gives the seed about four times the drag of a solid disc of the same size, using a fraction of the material. Dandelions have flown this way all along. We caught on in 2018.

Other plants take other roads. A coconut travels by sea, its seed sealed inside a husk that floats, keeps out water and carries enough food for weeks on the waves, ready to sprout when it washes up on some distant beach. The touch-me-not stores tension in its pods until the slightest contact bursts them, throwing the seeds out from under the parent's shade. Some seeds travel through time instead. Buried in desert dust, a seed can sit dormant for years with its metabolism almost halted, then, when rare rain finally falls, burst into growth with a promptness that looks very nearly like intent.

The standard answer is that better dispersers outlasted worse ones. Look at the methods again, though. Each is a finished package, with no gentle slope leading up to it. Get the seed weight wrong and a parachute fails in one of two ways: it drops like a stone or it blows away for good. A coconut that sinks simply rots. An exploding pod needs its coiled tension, its trigger and a casing strong enough to survive the blast, every piece at once. Selection can reward a disperser that already works. A half-finished one that carries its seed nowhere gives it nothing to reward. So the real question is where each complete, matched system came from to begin with.

Something odder still sits behind all this. A tree spends a fortune on fruit and seed, and most of that spending does the tree itself no good. Deer and worms eat the apples. The seeds that make it put down roots far away. The species and the wider ecosystem gain much more from the effort than the tree that paid for it. Call it what it is: generosity, open-handed and looking ahead, one individual's energy given for the many and for the future. A blind contest for individual survival is an odd place to find it.

Deception: orchids, and a mantis that is not hiding

"Do they not travel through the land so that their hearts may understand and their ears may listen? Indeed, it is not the eyes that are blind, but the hearts in the chests that grow blind." (Quran 22:46)

Some plants have reached strategies so precise it is hard to see them as anything other than intended. The bee orchid and the rest of the genus Ophrys pass themselves off as insects. The lip of the flower takes the shape, colour and even the surface texture of a female bee. More revealing still, the plant gives off a chemical blend that copies the sex pheromones of that particular bee species, and the botanist Florian Schiestl and his colleagues have identified the very compounds. A male bee follows a scent that promises a mate, tries to mate, and in the confusion collects pollen that he delivers to the next fake. The European bee orchid often falls back on pollinating itself in the cooler parts of its range, but across the genus the seduction is well documented.

Count up what the orchid has to get right for the trick to work, each independently and all at the same time: the outline, the feel of the surface, and most of all the exact chemical signature of a different species' pheromone. A random slip in any one and the male bee goes elsewhere. Chance mutation knows nothing of how a female bee looks or smells, yet generation after generation the orchid produces a forgery that works on several senses together. In some assays its scent blend draws males more strongly than a real female does. The forgery beats the original.

Animals use the trick too. The orchid mantis, a pale pink-and-white insect from Southeast Asia, was long assumed to hide among orchids by looking like one. In 2014 James O'Hanlon and colleagues found that it does something far bolder. It sits out in the open and serves as the bait. Through a pollinator's eyes its colour cannot be told apart from the local flowers, and it soaks up ultraviolet light just as real petals do, so a bee that sees in UV reads it as a bloom. In field trials, mantises set out on their own attracted wild pollinators at a higher rate than genuine flowers did. Then they ate them.

The disguise goes past appearance. Glands near the young mantis's mouth release compounds resembling the scent signals honeybees use with one another, so an incoming bee finds something that smells of the hive and looks like a flower. Two senses, fooled by one false bloom. What it presents is an ideal flower, matching no particular orchid, generic and more appealing than the real thing, built for bait. It was the first documented case of a predator drawing in prey by imitating a flower to two senses at once, and here again the forgery beats the original. Undirected accident would have to be a master forger to manage deception this specialised.

Specialists: the pitcher and the air plant

The verse about the bee speaks of dwellings, "Take for yourself among the mountains, houses...", and purpose-built provision of that kind runs through the plant world as well. The carnivorous pitcher plant lives in bogs so starved of nutrients that ordinary roots cannot draw up enough nitrogen, so it hunts. One of its leaves curls into a deep jug. Nectar and wax make the rim treacherous, and an insect lured by the sugar slips, drops into the fluid pooled at the bottom, and is dissolved by enzymes while the plant takes up what it needs. The plant has help with the digesting, too. Bacteria and insect larvae living in the pool work the prey down into the nitrogen the plant wants, so the trap arrives with a crew already aboard.

Each piece relies on the rest. Give the plant its lure without the enzymes and it catches food it cannot use; give it enzymes without the trap and it has nothing to use them on. Then the story takes a twist. Carnivory is an answer to poor soil, yet every trapped insect leaves its remains behind, and over time the plant enriches the very ground that made hunting necessary, until faster-growing ordinary plants move in and shade it out. A survival-maximising process has little reason to build and keep a trait that works to erase its own conditions. It reads far better as an assigned part in a larger economy: a specialist stationed where a specialist is needed.

If the pitcher plant specialises in bad soil, the air plant specialises in no soil at all. Tillandsia hangs from bare bark or clings to naked rock, having largely given up on roots as a way to feed. It drinks what it needs, moisture and nutrients alike, straight out of the air through microscopic scales on its leaves called trichomes. Each scale behaves like a non-return valve. In dry weather it lies down flat and seals the leaf, so nothing evaporates away. Once fog or rain wets it, its walls swell and lift, opening a passage that draws the water inward to the living tissue. Water gets a one-way ticket. That is the whole secret of a plant that lives on a branch with nothing in the ground: a settler equipped to bring life to surfaces that would otherwise stay barren.

"And you see the earth barren, but when We send down upon it rain, it stirs and swells and grows something of every beautiful kind. That is because Allah is the Truth, and it is He who gives life to the dead, and it is He who is over all things competent." (Quran 22:5–6)

The design reaches even into death. Soil organisms turn a fallen leaf into humus, and the humus feeds whatever grows next. A dead trunk becomes housing for insects and a store of nutrients released slowly over years. A healthy ecosystem wastes nothing. Temperate trees run their whole year on the same principle. In autumn the leaves come down. Through the killing cold of winter the tree stands bare and dormant, guarding itself by shutting down instead of feeding leaves it could not keep alive, and in spring the buds break open right on time. The whole sequence works as one integrated system. Shed the leaves without being able to grow new buds, or bud at the wrong moment, and the tree would not live through its first hard winter. Its provision for the cold has to be ready before the cold comes.

The chilli: one molecule, two messages

If you want to see a plant picking its audience in plain sight, bite into a chilli. All of its fire comes from a single compound, capsaicin, and the plant posts it at the door like a bouncer. In a mammal, capsaicin trips a pain receptor called TRPV1 and the mouth feels as though it is burning, which suits the plant nicely, since mammalian molars would grind its seeds to useless powder. Birds carry their own slightly different version of that receptor and feel nothing at all. They swallow the fruit whole and, some while later and some way off, drop the seeds unharmed. So one molecule says two opposite things. The seed-crusher is told to keep out, the seed-sower is waved through, and neither message goes to the wrong address. Chance had no reason to brew a chemical that knows a squirrel's teeth from a thrush's gut. Nor does it explain the third customer. We took a burn meant to see off squirrels and built a world cuisine around it.

Ready before the need

The widest objection tries to gather everything here into one answer. Plants adapt to where they live, it says, and natural selection explains all of it: desert succulents, pine needles, the waxy surface of an olive leaf. A careful biologist will tighten this by adding that selection plans nothing and has never said otherwise; it simply preserves whatever variant survives. Take that at face value and the problem gets harder. If nothing plans ahead, the working solution has to be on hand at the very moment it is needed.

Think of a plant in a climate that is drying out. It cannot begin to store water after the drought has come. Before the dry years arrive it needs the thick tissue that holds water, the waxy layer that slows evaporation and the smaller leaf surface, and in some desert plants the further trick of opening their pores only at night, so they can breathe without bleeding water into the midday heat. A lineage inching toward better drought tolerance dies in the first summer that moves faster than it does. The plant that lives to reproduce is the one already carrying the working answer.

Those answers go on to build whole worlds. Picture one acacia alone in the desert. Around it gathers an island of life: shade underneath, damp soil about the roots, a perch for birds and a shelter for insects, a small community built on the survival kit of a single tree. The design spills beyond the individual into entire networks of dependent life.

Then there is the larder. A surprising share of what plants make looks as though it was laid on less for the plant than for us. The potato and the carrot keep their savings buried in the dark, where no colour or sweetness is needed to bribe an animal into carrying seed away, and yet they are among the staples that feed the human race. The spice rack is stranger still. Cinnamon and clove owe their warmth, turmeric its earthy depth and the chilli its fire to compounds that, in many cases, work to put animals off. Those were defences. In human hands the warning label became the selling point, and the chemistry meant to stop a plant being eaten is the reason we grow it around the globe. So much of the green world feeds and delights the one creature able to stop and think about it. If that is coincidence, it is a remarkably hospitable one, and the Quran returns to it again and again, inviting us to notice provision of this kind and to be grateful.

Look again at the green blur beside the road. It is a layered, self-renewing system, powered by chemistry we cannot copy and held together by partnerships so finely tuned that we are still finding out how fine. Then check the running costs. Sunlight, water and air make up the entire bill, and for that a leaf will feed a continent, swapping out the protein at its core about every half hour in strong sun without ever pausing production. A century of human effort has yet to produce a working copy of the whole machine. The hedge you drove past this morning is the only technology on this planet that runs the whole world, and nobody has ever improved on it.

References

  • Quran 6:99, 16:68–69, 22:5, 50:7, 13:3, 22:46, 22:5–6 — verses quoted in the chapter.
  • Atmospheric oxygen and combustion limits (~15–25% window; ~21% present level) — standard fire-ecology and atmospheric-chemistry results, associated with Andrew Watson and colleagues on oxygen and fire regulation.
  • Great Oxidation Event ~2.4 billion years ago; oxygenic photosynthesis in cyanobacteria far earlier; animals ~600–540 million years ago — timeline of oxygen production relative to animal origins.
  • ATP synthase as a rotary molecular motor (rotation rates up to about 100 per second, measured in the bacterial motor; rates vary by organism and direction); Rubisco kinetics, abundance and the oxygenation side-reaction; thylakoid / electron-transport / Calvin-cycle architecture; D1 protein repair in Photosystem II — standard biochemistry.
  • Clarke, D., Whitney, H., Sutton, G., & Robert, D. (2013). "Detection and Learning of Floral Electric Fields by Bumblebees." Science 340 — floral electric fields and their detection and learning by bumblebees.
  • Sutton, G. P., Clarke, D., Morley, E. L., & Robert, D. (2016). "Mechanosensory hairs in bumblebees (Bombus terrestris) detect weak electric fields." PNAS 113 — filiform body hairs, not antennae, as the electroreceptors.
  • Karst, J., Jones, M. D., & Hoeksema, J. D. (2023). "Positive citation bias and overinterpreted results lead to misinformation on common mycorrhizal networks in forests." Nature Ecology & Evolution 7 — claims of forest-wide fungal networks, mother trees and warning signals outrun the field evidence. (~90% of land plants form mycorrhizal symbioses — standard figure.)
  • Cummins, C., et al. (2018). Nature — the separated vortex ring in dandelion flight, giving about four times the drag of a solid disc.
  • Schiestl, F. P., et al. — chemical (pheromone) mimicry in Ophrys orchids.
  • Horse chestnut (Aesculus hippocastanum) floral colour change (yellow→red) as a post-pollination nectar-guide signal — Sprengel's "traffic light" and successors.
  • O'Hanlon, J. C., Holwell, G. I., & Herberstein, M. E. (2014). "Pollinator Deception in the Orchid Mantis." The American Naturalist 183 — the mantis as a generic-flower lure (UV-absorbing colour) that out-attracts real flowers; later work on mandibular-gland compounds resembling honeybee pheromones adds the scent component.
  • Tewksbury, J. J., & Nabhan, G. P. (2001). "Directed deterrence by capsaicin in chillies." Nature 412 — mammals deterred via TRPV1, birds insensitive and effective seed dispersers.
  • Pitcher-plant trap mechanics and the in-fluid digestive community (bacteria and invertebrate larvae); nutrient feedback driving succession — standard botanical sources.
  • Tillandsia trichome as an asymmetric ("one-way valve") water-absorption structure — botanical sources.

Download the whole book (free PDF)