No Design · The chapters

Chapter 6: The Web of Life

By the How To Muslim team

"And We have placed in it, the earth, livelihoods for you and for those for whom you do not provide." (Quran 15:20)

Start with whatever is nearest. The seat taking your weight, this morning's breakfast, the breath you drew while reading that line. Every one of them leans on systems that were up and running long before anyone gave you a name. None of it was your doing. The soil that grew your wheat was built without you, and so were the insects that turned blossom into fruit and the cycle that keeps the atmosphere fit to breathe. You arrived to find the larder already stocked.

Notice how much the verse packs into one line. There are livelihoods on this earth for us, and also for a multitude of creatures we have never fed, never paid and seldom given a moment's thought. That leaves a simple question hanging. We are not supplying them. They are not, by any plan of their own, supplying themselves. So who set up this whole economy of life?

The trail this chapter follows runs through partnerships. Plenty of them are easygoing affairs, where either side could get by with someone else. The ones that carry the argument are exact fits, each partner shaped to the other like a key cut for a single lock. And one of them has been put through the bluntest test there is: scientists took a single piece away and recorded what fell apart.

Mutualism: the couplings that have to be exact

Mutualism is the biologist's word for a partnership between two species in which both come out ahead, and it turns up everywhere you look. Living things compete, certainly. They are also built, again and again, to work together.

The everyday example drifts past your window all summer. A bee drops into a flower for its nectar, gets coated in pollen while it drinks, and delivers that pollen to the next bloom along. One party gets a meal and the other gets offspring. Neither signed up for the arrangement or knows it exists, and still their behaviours mesh tightly enough to support whole ecosystems. Jeff Ollerton and his colleagues put the share of flowering plant species that rely on animals for pollination at around 87 percent, with bees ranking among the most important of those animals. Lose the pollinators, and most flowering plants lose the ability to reproduce at scale. Lose the flowers, and the pollinators go hungry.

The usual reply is that selection did it: species that cooperated outlasted species that didn't. Bees and flowers give that story room to work, because they are largely generalists. Plenty of bees work plenty of flowers, and a bee whose tongue runs a little short does not starve; it simply feeds somewhere else. The tight couplings are a different animal. There the fit has to be exact, and a near miss leaves both partners empty-handed. Those couplings exist, and they are where design shows its hand most plainly.

Darwin met the most celebrated of them. He was shown Angraecum sesquipedale, a Madagascan orchid that hides its nectar at the bottom of a spur close to a foot long, and he reasoned that the island must hold a moth whose tongue could reach all the way down. The suggestion was mocked. Then the moth was found, a hawkmoth with exactly the absurd tongue he had described, and today it bears the name praedicta, "the predicted one." A 2021 re-examination at the Natural History Museum promoted it from subspecies to full species. Photographs of the pollination itself had to wait until the 1990s, more than a hundred years after the forecast, finally joining prediction to mechanism. The orchid drew both camps from the start: the Duke of Argyll held it up as evidence of design, and in 1867 Wallace answered with the moth Darwin had predicted. Both men were staring at the same astonishing fit.

Like Hoyle's carbon resonance in Chapter 4 and Dirac's positron in Chapter 5, Darwin's moth was a forecast that nature kept, and he made it from the way two species mould each other. In effect he described a stranger's tongue from the depth of the keyhole. For me the most arresting part of the story is the thing he read: a coupling so precise that neither partner is any use to the other without the match. The spur reaches about thirty centimetres. When the moth was at last caught in 1903, forty-one years after Darwin's guess and well after his death, its tongue measured up to twenty-eight.

The fit has to hold from both sides. A tongue that falls short is the obvious failure: no reward, so the visits stop. A tongue far too long fails as well, and for the orchid it fails worse. Its owner could sip the nectar while hovering at a polite distance, head never touching the parts that hand over and collect pollen, like a contractor who cashes the cheque and never turns up on site. The partnership works only inside a narrow window, long enough to reach the nectar and short enough that reaching it means pressing in. That is one specification written into two organisms at once, each body setting the limits for the other. Machinists have a word for a limit like that, a tolerance, and a tolerance shared across two separate bodies is exactly what design looks like.

The clownfish: invisible to the weapon

By rights the clownfish should be lunch. Its sea anemone is armed with tentacles packed with stinging cells, enough to paralyse almost any fish careless enough to brush against them, and yet the clownfish threads through them all day and comes to no harm. It earns its lodging, too. It chases off animals that would graze on its host and feeds the anemone with the nutrients in its waste, and in exchange it lives somewhere no predator will follow.

The common explanation is a protective coat of slime. The real answer is cleverer. The anemone's stinging cells are choosy about what they shoot. They fire only when two things happen at once, a physical touch on the trigger and a chemistry that reads as food. What the cells taste for are certain sugars, sialic acids among them, that coat the skin of ordinary fish. Clownfish mucus runs low in exactly those compounds. Some are still there, at roughly half the concentration an ordinary fish carries, which sits below the level that registers as prey. The weapon looks straight at the clownfish and finds nothing to shoot. There are signs as well that each fish tunes its coat to its own particular anemone over time, which makes the fit adaptive on top of precise.

Survival comes down to a password, then. The clownfish gets through because its chemistry matches what a completely unrelated animal is checking for, and near misses earn nothing. Get the surface chemistry wrong and the outcome is the usual one for a fish in an anemone: stung, paralysed, eaten.

The cleaner wrasse: a small fish holding up a reef

Since Herodotus in the fifth century BC, people have told of a bird that strolls into a crocodile's open jaws and picks its teeth clean. No camera and no field scientist has ever caught one at it. The genuine cleaning station is out on a coral reef, and it beats the legend comfortably.

Its proprietor is the bluestreak cleaner wrasse, a small fish that sets up in one spot and waits for customers. They come from dozens of species, larger fish queuing to have parasites and dead tissue removed from their skin, their gills and the insides of their mouths. Redouan Bshary has spent decades watching these visits at Ras Mohammed in Egypt. A client hangs motionless in the water, gill covers flared wide. Predators big enough to swallow the wrasse in one gulp sit open-mouthed like patients in a dentist's chair, let it work inside their mouths, and let it leave.

What sets this partnership apart is that someone tested it by taking it away. Researchers removed the wrasse from patches of reef and kept those patches free of cleaners for years, and the effects arrived in sequence. Parasites on the client fish multiplied. Their stress hormones rose. Growth slowed. Then the fish began moving out, relocating to reefs where the service was still open for business.

Two studies did the heavy lifting. In the Red Sea, Bshary cleared patches of their cleaners for periods of four to twenty months and recorded the diversity draining away. On the Great Barrier Reef, a team at Lizard Island kept patches cleaner-free for eight and a half years, long enough to see the reef's new normal rather than its first reaction. The count of resident fish had fallen by about thirty-seven percent, and the number of species by twenty-three. Young fish settling in from elsewhere were down by around two thirds, and the surgeonfish by about the same.

The verdict came from a tape measure, not a hunch: a fish a few centimetres long holds up the diversity of an entire reef. Engineers know the pattern well. Pull out one small part that nobody was watching, and the structure around it starts to sag. That is the signature of an integrated system.

Underground: a trade with matched interfaces

"And the earth, We spread it out and set upon it firm mountains, and made grow in it every kind of beautiful plant." (Quran 50:7)

Go below the forest floor and you find trees and fungi in business together. The fungi wrap around the roots and grow into them, then push hair-fine threads called hyphae out through the soil, far beyond where the roots alone could reach, in search of water and of scarce nutrients such as phosphorus and nitrogen. The trees settle the account in sugar from photosynthesis, something a fungus has no way of making for itself.

It is not a cheap service. Worldwide estimates put the cost at around six percent of the carbon an arbuscular-mycorrhizal plant fixes and thirteen percent for the tree partnerships, climbing toward a quarter in some cases. Imagine handing over an eighth of your income, every year, for a single subscription. You would want it to be a very good subscription, and the size of the bill tells you the trade is real.

The name for all this is mycorrhizal symbiosis, and two facts about it change everything: it is ancient, and it is close to universal. The arrangement goes back more than four hundred million years, to the earliest plants that hauled themselves out of the water with no proper roots and no means of getting at a mineral unless a fungus brought it to them. Soils, forests and the carbon cycle all descend from this one interface. It is built into how dry land became habitable at all.

Neither side is running a charity. Toby Kiers and colleagues tagged the traded goods with isotopes and followed them across the boundary. The plants steered more carbon toward the fungi that brought them more phosphorus, the fungi steered more phosphorus toward the roots that paid them better, and either party cut back on a partner that underdelivered. So the interface comes with border guards on both sides, and nobody posts guards at a border with nothing crossing it.

You may have met the grander story that has grown up around these threads, the "Wood Wide Web" of mother trees feeding their kin and trees passing warnings through the fungi; in 2023 Justine Karst, Melanie Jones and Jason Hoeksema reviewed the evidence in Nature Ecology and Evolution and found those claims had run well ahead of the field data. The measured trade is the better story anyway: two kingdoms keeping careful accounts with each other.

Consider what it involves. Plant and fungus come from entirely separate kingdoms of life. Each supplies precisely what the other cannot produce, and they exchange it across a border made of microscopic threads, in a partnership so basic that most land plants depend on it. The question it raises has the same shape as the one endosymbiosis raised in Chapter 5. Pin down every detail the biologists have measured and the puzzle only sharpens: a trade agreement between two kingdoms, with matched and policed interfaces at both ends, had to come into being somehow, and contracts with matching clauses on both sides are not in the habit of writing themselves.

Seasons: keeping to a shared calendar

"And He has subjected for you the night and the day, the sun and the moon; and the stars are subjected by His command. Surely in that are signs for people who reason." (Quran 16:12)

Partnerships keep time, too, and whole communities of species that never meet run to one timetable.

Shorter autumn days set off a whole chain of responses. Deciduous trees let their leaves go, saving themselves water and energy, and the fallen leaves rot down into soil that feeds the very roots they came from. Up above, the birds are reading that fading light too. Every year the Arctic tern flies from the top of the world to the Antarctic and back, a commute that Carsten Egevang and colleagues tracked at around 71,000 kilometres on average; the longest single track on record came to just over 81,000. Its calendar is set by prey waiting at the far end. The bird needs to land as that food peaks, and a miss of only a few days can mean starving chicks.

Bears head the other way. After eating heavily all autumn, they settle into hibernation, where the heart drops from around fifty beats a minute to single figures and body temperature and metabolism fall with it. Life is very nearly on pause, and that creates a problem that ought to kill the animal. Months of lying still, without food or water, should leave a bear poisoned by its own nitrogen waste and stripped of muscle. Instead it recycles the waste, and it has help. Urea travels into the gut, bacteria living there split it apart, and the freed nitrogen returns to the liver to be assembled into new amino acids. In effect the bear has outsourced one step of its own nitrogen chemistry to its lodgers. It wakes in spring with none of the kidney damage or muscle loss that months of lying still would do to us, which is exactly why doctors study it. We cannot pull off the same trick.

Spring then clicks the whole system back into alignment: blossoms open as their pollinators emerge, and hibernators surface hungry just as there is forage to find. The insects boom on cue, and the migrant birds arrive to eat them.

Selection sharpens the timing, certainly: a species that gets it wrong leaves fewer young, and co-evolution tunes each partner's response to the cues it reads. Look, though, at what the whole adds up to: dozens of species, spread across two hemispheres, holding to one calendar that none of them can see in full. The tern knows nothing of the bear, and the flower has never heard of the tern. They stay in time together because the clock they each consult, night following day and the sun's yearly course, keeps steady time. The verse calls night and day, sun and moon, subjected, and the living world sets its calendar by them.

Toxoplasma: a life cycle built around one deficiency

"Do you not see that Allah has subjected to you whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth, and lavished upon you His blessings, both seen and unseen?" (Quran 31:20)

Not every partnership is easy to admire, and some of the least lovable are the most revealing. Take the parasite that drives its host.

Toxoplasma gondii is a single cell with one very particular need: it can reproduce sexually only inside the gut of a cat. It leaves in the cat's faeces and gets swallowed by rodents foraging on the ground. Once inside a rat or a mouse, it slips across the blood-brain barrier, settles into cysts in the brain and alters the chemistry of fear. Infected rodents lose their healthy dread of cats. Some studies even find them drawn to the scent of cat urine, which makes them easier to catch, and a rodent that gets eaten carries the parasite straight back to the only place it can complete its cycle.

Manuel Berdoy, Joanne Webster and others documented this around 2000, with later work by Ajai Vyas. In 2020 Madlaina Boillat and colleagues reported in Cell Reports how far the effect reaches: infection brings inflammation in the brain that lowers anxiety and predator-fear generally, fear of cats included. A single cell reaches into a rodent's brain and adjusts what the animal is afraid of, to the benefit of its own life cycle. For an organism with no brain of its own, it is remarkably handy with someone else's.

It comes equipped for the work. Toxoplasma carries its own genes for tyrosine hydroxylase, the enzyme that sets the pace of dopamine production. Finding the tools for making a host's neurotransmitter inside a single-celled organism is a startling thing.

The most telling detail, though, settles a question the behaviour leaves open. Why cats in particular?

Because of a broken enzyme. A cat's intestine lacks a working version of delta-6-desaturase, so linoleic acid piles up there instead of being processed further along. In 2019 Martorelli Di Genova and colleagues showed that this odd fatty environment is exactly what Toxoplasma needs to finish its sexual reproduction. Recreate the same fatty-acid conditions in a mouse, and the parasite will reproduce sexually in the mouse. Its entire elaborate itinerary, across more than one host and through a rodent's brain on the way, is built around a single hole in feline biochemistry.

Think about what that means. The parasite's reproduction is keyed to a chemical quirk of a single family of mammals, and every other stage of its existence works as a delivery route to that one address. The rat's brain is just a stop on the road to a cat's gut.

The wasp and the spider: step after step

Precision of this sort is the ordinary currency of parasites. When a tick feeds it is doing far more than biting: it injects a blend of proteins that numbs the wound, keeps the blood from clotting and calms the host's immune defences, so dinner carries on unnoticed. A tapeworm anchors itself to the gut wall with a crown of hooks and suckers, and since it lives bathed in food that has already been digested, it has done without a gut altogether and takes in nutrients through its skin. Mistletoe sinks specialised roots into a tree's water supply and drinks from it, all while making its own food by photosynthesis.

Then there is the wasp that hires a spider as its builder, and slow accumulation has a hard time with it.

In Costa Rica, the entomologist William Eberhard followed in detail what certain ichneumonid wasps do to orb-weaving spiders. The wasp fixes an egg to the spider. After hatching, the larva stays put and drinks the spider's body fluids without killing it, while the spider goes on building ordinary webs as though nothing were wrong. On the night before the larva is due to pupate, the spider changes jobs. It abandons the familiar orb and spins something it never otherwise makes, a strange, reinforced structure shaped to hold a cocoon up off the ground and shield it from ants. Once the shelter is finished the spider is killed, and the larva spins its cocoon inside the made-to-order home its victim built.

So how does a larva commission a building? Later research points to chemistry. The larva seems to dose the spider with a substance that mimics a molting hormone, and spiders under its influence show raised levels of 20-hydroxyecdysone, the molting hormone itself. One neat experiment reveals what sort of signal this is. Pluck the larva off before that final night and the spider keeps spinning cocoon webs for several days, only gradually returning to orbs. The wasp leaves behind a program, one that keeps running in the spider's system long after its author has gone. That is a much harder trick than mere interference.

What makes the case so hard is the order of operations more than the intricacy. Picture everything the very first wasp of this kind needed in place, all at once and in sequence. A secretion that quiets the spider without killing it. A larva able to live on its host without being destroyed by the host's immune system. Feeding that stops before the spider dies too soon. And, at precisely the right moment, a chemical cue that turns ordinary web-building into a protective shelter. No gentle ramp leads up to this, with each half-step paying its own way. A wasp that picks the wrong host, triggers the wrong web or misjudges the timing at any stage leaves no descendants to try again. Every step is dead weight until the ones before it are already running.

The obvious reply is that the wasp hijacks a routine the spider already owns, the sequence it runs before molting, and that this makes the job considerably easier. Easier, yes. Even a hijacker needs the right chemical at the right stage in the right host, aimed at the one dormant routine that will do the job. That is a lock and its key belonging to two different species, and the gradual story has to bring them together with no working halfway version to keep along the way.

What we inherited

Each of these partnerships is a single thread in a much bigger weave. Forests take carbon dioxide out of the air and put oxygen back. Microbes in the soil decompose the dead, return their nutrients to circulation and build the rich ground our crops grow in. Pollinators give us the fruits, nuts and seeds that sit at the foundation of human diets. Rivers and lakes irrigate the land and shelter more species than anyone could count.

The Quran describes all of this as provision, set in place on purpose for us and for creatures we will never feed. It casts us as the ones who receive and reminds us that we are not the ones who supply. No human makes the rain fall. None of us runs photosynthesis or pollinates a field. Our main contribution to the arrangement has been to turn up hungry. What we have, we inherited, and it came to us already working.

An inheritance like that brings duties with it. Cut forests faster than they regrow, poison the rivers, push species into extinction, and we are dismantling a house we never built and could not build again. The cleaner wrasse study shows the danger in miniature: take out one unassuming part and a reef loses a third of its fish. Usually we discover which parts were holding everything up only after they have gone.

What the network amounts to

Now stand back far enough to see the whole.

Loose partnerships are everywhere; the exact fits are what stop you in your tracks. The orchid and its moth set limits on each other's bodies from both directions, and the clownfish passes a chemical password check set by an unrelated animal. Take the cleaner wrasse away and a reef drains of its diversity, as the experiment showed. Plant and fungus run a trade across two kingdoms, policed at both ends. Species that never meet keep one calendar across two hemispheres. Toxoplasma has organised its whole existence around one enzyme missing in one family of mammals. And the wasp works through a sequence in which nothing is useful until everything before it works.

Put together, life on earth is a web of dependencies and provisions working at every scale, and it was running long before we showed up to draw on it.

The verse says it in a single line: livelihoods placed here for us, and for all those we do not provide for. Stay with that second half for a moment. Most of what this chapter has described was never arranged for our sake and has no need of us whatever. The wrasse keeps the reef clean with or without an audience. The fungus was feeding plants for hundreds of millions of years before anyone thought to give it a name. We walked late into a household that was already running and were given a share in it, as guests, with a guest's duties. The table was laid before we sat down, and it is still being laid, season after season, for us and for all those for whom we do not provide.

References

  • Quran 15:20, 50:7, 16:12, 31:20 — verse texts as quoted.
  • Ollerton, J., et al. (2011). "How many flowering plants are pollinated by animals?" Oikos 120 — ~87.5% of angiosperms are animal-pollinated.
  • Darwin, C. (1862) — predicted, from co-evolutionary reasoning, a long-tongued pollinator for Angraecum sesquipedale; Xanthopan morganii praedicta later confirmed it.
  • Angraecum sesquipedale nectar spur ~29–33 cm; Xanthopan morganii praedicta proboscis up to ~28 cm, described by Rothschild & Jordan (1903), 41 years after Darwin's 1862 prediction. A proboscis too short cannot reach the reward; one much too long extracts nectar without contacting the pollinia, so the plant is not pollinated.
  • Cnidocyte discharge requires both mechanical stimulation and chemoreceptor activation (surface N-acetylated sugars incl. sialic acid); clownfish mucus lacks the triggering profile (Lubbock 1980; Watson & Mire-Thibodeaux 1994), with acclimation to a host anemone (Elliott et al. 1995).
  • Clownfish mucus: sialic acid at 13–16 µM in anemone symbionts against 21–30 µM in non-symbionts (Roux et al., 2024); the coat is trigger-poor rather than trigger-free. Discharge gating requires mechanical and chemical signals together (Weir et al., 2020, eLife).
  • Egyptian plover and crocodile "tooth-cleaning" — traceable to Herodotus (5th c. BC); never documented photographically or scientifically.
  • Bshary, R., et al. — cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus) mutualism; removal effects mediated by rising gnathiid isopod parasite loads, elevated stress hormones, reduced growth, and client emigration (Journal of Animal Ecology, 2003, and related work).
  • Cleaner wrasse removals: Bshary (2003, J. Anim. Ecol.), Red Sea, 4–20 months, diversity decline; Waldie et al. (2011, PLoS ONE), Lizard Island, 8.5 years, resident abundance −37%, species richness −23%, juvenile visitors −65%, acanthurids −66%.
  • Mycorrhizal carbon cost: Hawkins et al. (2023, New Phytologist) estimate ~6% of net primary production for arbuscular and ~13% for ectomycorrhizal plants; Hobbie (2006) gives ~4–25% for ectomycorrhizal trees as the upper range.
  • Mycorrhizal symbiosis dates to the origin of land plants, over 400 million years ago; the first rootless colonisers depended on fungal partners for mineral access.
  • Kiers, E. T., et al. (2011). Science — reciprocal reward and sanction in the plant–fungus exchange, demonstrated by isotope tracing ("biological market").
  • Karst, J., Jones, M. D., & Hoeksema, J. D. (2023). "Positive citation bias and overinterpreted results lead to misinformation on common mycorrhizal networks in forests." Nature Ecology & Evolution — claims of forest-wide networks, "mother tree" provisioning of kin, and inter-tree warning signals outrun the field evidence.
  • Egevang, C., et al. (2010). PNAS — Arctic tern migration: mean ~70,900 km, range 59,500–81,600 km.
  • Ursid nitrogen recycling: urea hydrolysed by gut microbial urease to ammonia, reincorporated into amino acids via hepatic pathways, preventing azotemia and muscle atrophy during hibernation (Nelson et al., 1975; Barman et al., 2020; comparative physiology literature).
  • Berdoy, M., Webster, J. P., & Macdonald, D. W. (2000), Proc. R. Soc. B; Vyas, A., et al. (2007), PNAS — "fatal feline attraction" in infected rodents. Boillat, M., et al. (2020), Cell Reports — infection reduces anxiety and predator-fear generally, linked to brain inflammation.
  • Gaskell, E. A., et al. (2009), PLOS ONE — Toxoplasma gondii encodes tyrosine hydroxylase genes.
  • Martorelli Di Genova, B., et al. (2019), PLOS Biology — feline delta-6-desaturase deficiency produces the intestinal linoleic-acid environment Toxoplasma requires for sexual reproduction; supplying it permits sexual reproduction in mice.
  • Eberhard, W. G. (2000–2010) — Hymenoepimecis wasp manipulation of orb-weaver web-building; ecdysteroid (20-hydroxyecdysone) linkage.

Download the whole book (free PDF)