No Design · The chapters

Chapter 11: Mathematics and Nature

By the How To Muslim team

"And the heaven He raised high, and He set up the balance." (Quran 55:7)

Spend a clear night watching the moon. Hour after hour it slides along a path so dependable that astronomers can tell you where it will hang in the sky centuries from now. The mathematics that predicts it belongs to the same family that describes seeds crowding into a sunflower head and a hurricane wheeling over the ocean. A moon, a flower and a storm have nothing obvious in common, yet one kind of mathematics runs all three. That is a clue, and a large one, to the sort of world we have been placed in.

Here is the claim, then. Reality speaks mathematics, right down to its roots, and that is among the clearest signs we have of a Mind behind it. Once you have seen the point, it is remarkably hard to talk your way back out of it.

You may know a popular version of this idea, in which a single magic number, the golden ratio, is stamped across the whole of creation. The real story is more remarkable. It starts in a sunflower and it ends in a puzzle that physicists themselves find genuinely mysterious.

The sunflower and the golden angle

Begin with a pair of ones and keep adding the last two numbers you have: 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, and on without end. That is the Fibonacci sequence, and plants build with it. Botanists call the way a plant lays out its leaves, seeds and scales phyllotaxis, and the sequence is sitting right there for anyone patient enough to count.

Look hard at a sunflower and you will see its seeds set in two families of spirals, one family sweeping one way and the other sweeping back across it. Count each family and the totals are usually next-door neighbours in the sequence: thirty-four and fifty-five, say, or fifty-five and eighty-nine if the flower is a big one. A pine cone wears the same crossed spirals on its scales, and so does a pineapple, while leaves wind their way up a stem one at a time at a fixed angle. That angle is what holds the whole arrangement together. It is the golden angle, roughly 137.5 degrees, which is simply the golden ratio expressed as a portion of a full turn.

The pattern earns its place. Set each new leaf or seed at that angle and overlap is kept to a minimum, so the plant crams the most into the least room. It is packing, and superb packing.

But why this particular angle? Two physicists, Stéphane Douady and Yves Couder, found out in 1992 with an experiment of real elegance. Into the middle of a dish of oil they dripped magnetised droplets, one after another. Every drop pushed away the drops already there, and was shoved outward in its turn by the drop that followed. Once the drip rate passed a threshold, the droplets settled, unprompted, onto the golden angle, laying out Fibonacci spiral counts as they went. The dish held oil, magnetism and nothing alive.

Here is the part I keep coming back to. Living plants reach the same result by a route of their own. In the decades since that experiment, plant scientists have uncovered the molecular workings of phyllotaxis. Cells hand a growth hormone called auxin along from one to the next, and a new leaf appears wherever the earlier leaves have drained the hormone furthest. Swap magnetism for chemistry and you have the dish's repulsion rule all over again. One is a dish of oil, the other a growing shoot, and both land on the same angle by the same mathematics. So the pattern belongs to neither of them. It lives in the arithmetic they both obey. The droplets found the golden angle every bit as surely as the sunflower does, and droplets do not photosynthesise.

That arithmetic is a small jewel of pure mathematics. In a precise technical sense, the golden ratio is the most irrational number there is, meaning that no number is harder to approximate with a fraction. This is exactly what a growing plant needs. Choose an angle that is a simple fraction of a circle and, after a few turns, new growth starts lining up in straight rays with wasted gaps between them. The golden angle never falls into step, however many turns the shoot makes, and that is why it packs better than any other.

None of this asks the plant to know any mathematics; physics does the sums. Now see what that implies, because the honeycomb in Chapter 7 taught us the same lesson. The best pattern turns up because the laws of nature are set up so that it will. A sunflower that could compute would be a curiosity. A reality built so that simple physical rules converge on a deep mathematical optimum is far more wonderful than that. The mathematics is in the laws from the start.

One number on tour

The golden ratio, roughly 1.618, has picked up a fan club, and the fan club hands out membership generously. The human body, the Parthenon, the Mona Lisa, the DNA helix, spiral galaxies and, most famously, the nautilus shell have all been signed up. The mathematician George Markowsky set the claims beside the evidence in a 1992 paper, and they do not survive the meeting. Clement Falbo measured real nautilus shells and found them widening by about 1.33 per quarter turn, across a range from about 1.24 to 1.43; a golden spiral needs 1.618. The DNA figure of 34 by 21 ångströms works only because the molecule's 20-ångström diameter gets written as 21, which happens to be a Fibonacci number. Round generously, pick your landmarks after the fact, and any constant will turn up anywhere you please.

The nautilus never needed the borrowed title. Its shell is a logarithmic spiral, elegant in its own right, and galaxies and hurricanes trace logarithmic spirals too. Nature keeps a whole library of mathematics, and it is far more interesting than one number on tour.

The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics

Now for the real marvel: the universe is mathematical through and through, and nobody can quite say why.

Eugene Wigner gave the puzzle its famous label. In 1960 the Nobel-winning physicist published an essay with a title that does most of the arguing, "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences." The power of mathematics to capture the physical world was, in his words, "a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve." That is a striking thing for a physicist to say about the very tool he used every working day. He could see the gift plainly. What he could not say was where it came from.

Picture what he had in mind. A mathematician follows a structure because it is beautiful or puzzling, chasing its inner logic with no application anywhere in view. A generation passes, sometimes several, and then physicists open the same pages and find the machinery of the physical world already laid out there. In physics this has happened again and again, often enough to count as part of the pattern of discovery. Mathematicians, it seems, keep writing out the answers before physics has got round to the questions.

Bernhard Riemann is the classic case. Back in the 1850s, with nothing in mind beyond the mathematics itself, he explored what geometry becomes once space is allowed to curve and Euclid's flat world is left behind. About sixty years later Einstein realised that gravity is nothing other than spacetime bending. To say so precisely he needed a mathematics of curved space, and Riemann had already built one, long before anybody knew what it was for.

Early in the twentieth century David Hilbert and others were studying vector spaces with infinitely many dimensions, about as remote from practical life as mathematics gets. Then, in the 1920s, quantum mechanics arrived, and it turned out to be written in exactly that language. The match is exact: the state of a quantum system is a vector in a Hilbert space, full stop.

Group theory has an even odder history. Évariste Galois developed it in the 1830s while working out which equations could be solved, and a duel ended his life when he was twenty. His groups then waited more than a century for their second career, as the description of the symmetries that govern the subatomic world. In 1961 Murray Gell-Mann, with Yuval Ne'eman reaching the same result independently, laid out the known particles in the pattern that one of those symmetry groups requires. The pattern had a hole in it. Something belonged in the gap that nobody had ever detected, and they stated what it should weigh. Three years on, the omega-minus turned up close to the predicted mass. Follow the chain from end to end: a young man's question about algebraic equations, posed in the nineteenth century, ended with physicists hunting a particle, and finding it where the algebra told them to look.

Complex numbers have a similar story. They were introduced as a formal trick for solving equations and for a long time carried a faint air of disrepute. Quantum mechanics cannot do without them.

Chapter 5 gave us the sharpest example of all. When Dirac's equation insisted on a mirror-image twin of the electron, he took it at its word, and four years later the positron turned up.

Galileo put it four centuries ago: the book of nature is written in the language of mathematics. The fit is tightest exactly where it matters most. The deepest laws of physics are short, elegant mathematical statements, and nothing obliged a universe to be built that way. It might have been a sprawl with no clean description anywhere, every situation needing its own improvised rule. What we have instead is order all the way down, expressed in a language that mathematicians had often written out before anyone suspected nature was speaking it.

The second half of the mystery

Einstein was struck most of all by the other half of the puzzle. The world is written in mathematics, and we can actually read what is written.

"The most incomprehensible thing about the world," he wrote, "is that it is comprehensible."

Hold the two facts together and they carry you past physics altogether. Ask what a mind actually needs to stay alive. It must gauge how far off the river is, tell one wolf from three, and see where a flung stone will land. No ancestor was ever eaten for want of the field equations of general relativity. Nobody's survival hung on a theorem about infinite sets, or on knowing what goes on in the heart of a star. And still the mathematics that runs the universe at its deepest level lies far above anything survival demanded, and we can do it anyway. Chapter 3 found this surplus in the human mind and Chapter 4 found it in our unobstructed view of the sky. Here it turns up in its purest and most abstract form.

A message in a language is a sign of an author fluent in it. When the message is in a language its reader is able to learn, it points further still, toward an author who wrote with that reader in view.

Snowflakes: order that never repeats

"Do you not see that Allah drives the clouds, then joins them together, then piles them into a mass, and you see the rain come forth from within it?" (Quran 24:43)

Every snowflake starts with a speck of dust. High in a cloud, water vapour freezes onto it, and the result is a tiny crystal of ice with six sides. Those six sides come from chemistry. A water molecule is not straight but bent, always at the same angle, and when the molecules lock together that bend herds them into a hexagonal lattice. Ice, in other words, is born hexagonal. As the young crystal drops and tumbles, it passes through pockets of the cloud that are warmer or colder, damper or drier, and its six corners sprout outward into six arms.

Kenneth Libbrecht at Caltech has spent decades studying snow crystals and growing them under controlled conditions, and the snow he finds is mostly lopsided and uneven. The perfect six-pointed stars you see in photographs are the rare few, picked out for their beauty. The blobs never make the photo books.

When symmetry does appear, the reason is lovely in itself: the six arms match because they have lived the same life. A crystal only a few millimetres wide meets every change in temperature and humidity at the same moment across its whole body, and ice is exquisitely sensitive to those conditions, so six arms put through an identical sequence tend to answer it identically. Where conditions differ from one side of the crystal to the other, as they often do, the flake comes out lopsided. Where they don't, you get sextuplets that have never exchanged a word.

So every snowflake carries two things at once. Underneath is a strict order, the hexagon set by the shape of one molecule. Over it runs variety without end, because each crystal's route through the cloud is its own, and its pattern has almost certainly never been grown before and will not be grown again. Order that never repeats. Call it law-governed particularity: simple rules yielding individuality without limit, with nothing random in it and nothing mechanical either. The hexagon is the script, and each flake is a word written in it once and never again.

The pattern beneath the patterns

Line up the cases side by side: the golden angle in the sunflower, the hexagon in the snowflake, the ellipse traced by an orbit. They are glimpses of one thing, a cosmos whose laws are mathematical at their foundations, which is why simple rules keep throwing up elegant, often optimal order at every scale.

We keep finding mathematics already in place, waiting for us, often worked out on paper decades before anyone knew what it described. This is what Wigner meant by unreasonable effectiveness, a gift we neither understand nor deserve.

People have tried hard to explain it away. Richard Hamming suggested the fit is partly our own doing: we select and shape mathematics until it matches whatever we are studying. Ivor Grattan-Guinness held that much of the apparent prophecy is hindsight, stitched together by historians who already know the ending. Derek Abbott turned the question round and documented how spectacularly ineffective most mathematics is for most of nature. Max Tegmark went the other way entirely and proposed that the universe simply is a mathematical structure, which makes the gap vanish by definition and still leaves you asking why its structure is so elegant and why a mind inside it can read it. Four explanations, several of them flatly contradicting one another, and none has won general assent. When the locksmiths disagree this much, the door is still locked. Three of the four push hard enough to deserve a reply.

Take Hamming first. Shape mathematics to suit a phenomenon and of course it fits; that much he explains. The trouble is the timing in the cases above. Riemann completed non-Euclidean geometry some sixty years ahead of need, without a thought for gravity, and when Einstein went looking for a tool he found it sitting finished on the shelf. Nobody tailors a suit for a customer who has not yet been born.

Grattan-Guinness's charge cuts deeper. Tally only the hits and you can conjure any pattern you like, which is exactly how the golden-ratio legend was built. But that charge only bites on coincidences, and these were predictions. Gell-Mann named a particle no one had ever seen, said it had to exist, and gave its mass in advance. Three years later it appeared at 1,672 million electronvolts, against a forecast of about 1,680. Dirac's positron came the same way. Hindsight cannot reach back and plant a discovery that had not yet been made.

That leaves Derek Abbott, whose challenge sounds the most dangerous of the three and ends up helping. On the facts he is right. Most of mathematics corresponds to nothing in nature, and plenty of nature shrugs off our equations; ask one for next month's weather, or for the true length of a coastline, and see how far you get. But notice where the misses cluster. They pile up among tangled, complicated systems such as turbulence, ecosystems, economies and the weather. The hits pile up at the bottom layer, where the laws themselves are set. That pattern gives the game away. A tool we had merely fitted to the world through practice ought to do best with the everyday tangle and worst at the deep foundations. Mathematics does the reverse: it stumbles over whatever is built from the rules and is uncannily good at the rules themselves, which is just what you would expect if the rules were written in mathematics from the start.

Sixty-five years after Wigner named it, the gift still has no agreed explanation. Look at it whole, though: a universe written in a language, and a reader equipped to read it. Put those two together and you arrive at the question the Quran presses again and again. Who wrote it, and for whom?

The verse at the head of this chapter points to the answer: "And the heaven He raised high, and He set up the balance." That balance is there in the sunflower's angle and the snowflake's hexagon, in Riemann's curved spaces and in the omega-minus waiting at 1,672 million electronvolts. And we were given the eyes to read it.

References

  • Quran 55:7, 24:43 — the verses quoted in this chapter. Mīzān in 55:7 means balance, measure.
  • Douady, S., & Couder, Y. (1992). "Phyllotaxis as a physical self-organized growth process." Physical Review Letters 68 — the golden angle as a dynamical attractor: drops of ferrofluid dripped at the centre of a dish of silicone oil in a vertical magnetic field settle into golden-angle spacing and Fibonacci spiral counts, without any biology.
  • Reinhardt, D., et al. (2003). "Regulation of Phyllotaxis by Polar Auxin Transport." Nature 426 — the molecular implementation in plants of the same repulsion rule.
  • The golden ratio as the "most irrational" number: its continued fraction is [1; 1, 1, 1, …], making it the least well approximated by rationals (Hurwitz's theorem), hence optimal for non-aligning packing. Golden angle ≈137.508°.
  • Markowsky, G. (1992). "Misconceptions about the Golden Ratio." The College Mathematics Journal 23 — human proportions, the Parthenon, the Mona Lisa and related golden-ratio claims checked against the evidence.
  • Falbo, C. (2005). The College Mathematics Journal 36(2), 123–134 — Nautilus pompilius growth 1.24–1.43 per quarter turn, mean ≈1.33, against the 1.618 a golden spiral requires; the shell is a logarithmic spiral.
  • B-form DNA has a diameter of ~20 Å, commonly written as 21 Å to form a Fibonacci pair with the 34 Å helical pitch.
  • Wigner, E. (1960). "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences." Communications in Pure and Applied Mathematics 13.
  • Cases of abstract mathematics preceding physical application: Riemann (1850s) → general relativity (1915); Hilbert spaces (early 20th c.) → quantum mechanics (1920s); Galois/group theory (1830s) → particle symmetries and predicted particles (1960s); complex numbers → quantum formalism; Dirac (1928) → positron (1932).
  • Gell-Mann, M. (1961) — the "Eightfold Way"; SU(3) symmetry predicted the Ω⁻ baryon and its approximate mass before its discovery at Brookhaven in 1964. Ne'eman, Y. (1961, Nuclear Physics 26) — independent derivation of the same SU(3) classification. Ω⁻ predicted ≈1,680 MeV, observed 1,672.45 MeV (Barnes et al., 1964, PRL 12, 204).
  • Proposed accounts of mathematics' effectiveness: Hamming (1980, Amer. Math. Monthly), Grattan-Guinness (1990, History of Science), Abbott (2013, Proc. IEEE), Tegmark (2008, Found. Phys.). None has won general assent.
  • Galileo, Il Saggiatore (1623) — the book of nature written in the language of mathematics.
  • Einstein, A. (1936). "Physik und Realität" ("Physics and Reality") — "the eternal mystery of the world is its comprehensibility," usually rendered in English as "The most incomprehensible thing about the world is that it is comprehensible."
  • Libbrecht, K. G. (Caltech) — snow-crystal physics: the hexagonal lattice arises from water's molecular geometry; most real snowflakes are irregular, and symmetric stellar dendrites are a photogenic minority; arm similarity comes from shared growth history through the same conditions.

Download the whole book (free PDF)