No Design · The chapters

Chapter 12: The Art of Migration

By the How To Muslim team

"And it is He who made the stars for you, that you may be guided by them through the darkness of land and sea. We have detailed the signs for a people who know." (Quran 6:97)

Step out on a clear night, tip your head back, and you are looking at a navigation chart. The stars are beautiful, of course. For a great many creatures they are also equipment, consulted night after night by animals that cannot afford a misreading. The verse names that purpose outright: among the reasons the stars were placed where they are is to guide travellers through the darkness of land and sea.

And the animals put that purpose to work. A songbird no heavier than a few coins, a butterfly that weighs less than a paperclip: both cover astonishing distances, and both do it by consulting the sun, the night sky and the magnetism of the earth itself.

What they carry for the trip is a whole navigation suite: compasses built on entirely different physics, each able to stand in when another goes dark, and the magnetic one paired with a dedicated region of the brain that reads it. In the monarch butterfly there is something stranger still: a route and a timetable handed down through generations, not one of which lives to see the whole journey. That integration, and the information behind it, is where the design shows most clearly.

The star compass: a rule that reads any sky

A great many migrants travel by night, crossing whole continents with the stars as part of their guidance. We understand this feat unusually well, thanks to experiments Stephen Emlen ran between 1967 and 1970.

His subjects were indigo buntings and his laboratory was a planetarium. He rearranged the artificial heavens overhead and noted which way the birds tried to fly. As the earth spins, the whole sky appears to pivot around one spot close to the Pole Star, the patch that hardly moves at all, and the buntings were steering by that pivot. In autumn, heading away from it meant south. Then Emlen shifted the planetarium's pole onto another star, and the birds, without a murmur of protest, turned to follow it.

You will often hear that the bird hatches with its star map already loaded. The truth is cleverer. Young buntings learn the sky. As chicks, long before their first migration, they watch the stars wheel overhead night after night and work out for themselves where the centre of rotation lies.

Then came the test that settled it, and I find it delightful. Emlen reared a batch of buntings beneath a planetarium sky made to spin around Betelgeuse, an ordinary star in Orion and nowhere near the celestial pole. When those birds came of age, Betelgeuse was their pole star. They took their bearings from it.

So no chart of particular constellations comes with the egg, and a good thing too, because a chart would have failed. The earth's axis wobbles like a spinning top, tracing one slow circle roughly every twenty-six thousand years, and as it turns the star at the still point changes. Polaris has not always had the job. When the pyramids of Egypt were going up, the pole belonged to Thuban, in Draco. A lineage born with Thuban fixed as north would now be flying about sixty-four degrees off course every night: the better part of a right angle. A map in the genes would have carried an expiry date, and it would have fallen well inside recorded history.

What the bird inherits is a rule: find the still point the heavens turn around, and orient by that. It arrives in the world equipped to assemble a star compass from any sky it is handed.

Think about what kind of thing that is. A map is a set of data, and data goes stale. A rule that draws the map fresh from whatever sky is overhead is a program, and it keeps giving the right answer while the sky slowly shifts. The bunting inherits the method rather than the answer, which is exactly the right thing to inherit when the answer is going to move.

Many compasses, one sense of direction

The stars are only one instrument on board. There is also a magnetic compass, which we now partly understand down to the level of molecules. As we saw in Chapter 1, it rests on a retinal protein called cryptochrome, where light kicks off quantum-scale reactions that respond to the earth's magnetic field. In daylight the bird reads the sun instead, using an internal clock to allow for the sun's steady movement. And there is evidence of a second magnetic system, quite separate from the first: crystals of magnetite, reporting through the trigeminal nerve, which seem to register the field's intensity rather than its direction. That gives the bird something nearer a map than a compass. All told, it adds up to a well-stocked instrument panel for so small a traveller.

Better still, each of these senses works on its own, and each covers for the others when they are unavailable. When cloud rolls over the stars, the magnetic compass simply carries on; that is the very situation it backs up. Put a bird under an overcast sky and magnetic cues alone are enough for it to hold its heading. The system is redundant, which is to say fault-tolerant, and fault tolerance is one of the clearest marks careful engineering leaves behind.

We recognise it at once in our own machines. A well-designed aircraft carries several independent instruments precisely so that no single failure brings it down, and nobody looks at that cockpit and sees an absence of design. Now look at the bird. Its channels run on wholly different physics: quantum chemistry in the retina, magnetite mechanics in the beak, the rotation of the night sky, the sun's bearing through the day. All of them feed a single, unified sense of direction. Blending inputs that share no common currency is hard, and here it is done as a matter of course. Our own engineers call this graceful degradation, and they are rather pleased with themselves when they manage it. The bird does it on every flight.

Every instrument also needs a reader, and a sensor with nothing to interpret it is an ornament. In night-migratory songbirds the magnetic sense runs through Cluster N, a specialised patch of forebrain that switches on only at night and only during migratory behaviour. Disable Cluster N and the bird loses its magnetic orientation, while its sun and star compasses go on working.

So the bird carries a matched pair: a quantum-chemical detector in its eye and, in its forebrain, a dedicated region to read what that detector reports. Cryptochrome keeps busy with other jobs in the eye, and a night-vision region has uses beyond reading a compass, yet neither one, alone, is a compass. The detector by itself broadcasts to an empty room. The brain region by itself sits by a phone that never rings. Spare compasses elsewhere in the bird change nothing here, because this pairing sits inside the magnetic compass itself. The compass lives in the pairing.

This is a shape we have met before, in the dolphins calling one another by name in Chapter 3, in the genetic code in Chapter 5 and in the honeybee's waggle dance in Chapter 7. In each case a signal and its reader have to be matched, and physics does not hand out the matching for free.

Whales: a compass we have not yet found

Out at sea the puzzle gets harder. A migrating whale may swim thousands of miles through open water without a single landmark. Its methods are harder to study than a bird's, and our picture of them is less complete.

The leading idea is magnetic. Whales may sense the earth's field and trace the contours of magnetic variation in the crust beneath them, which would turn a featureless basin into a network of invisible highways. They also have the ocean's soundscape, and the deep sea has a real feature that makes this plausible. At a certain depth the speed of sound drops to its minimum, and low-frequency sound that strays into that layer gets bent back in, so it can travel thousands of kilometres instead of fading out. A whale call pitched in that range can carry clear across an ocean basin. Whether whales use this channel to find their way, and not only to talk, is still an open question.

We may not know yet which instrument the whale is reading, but we know it is reading one. Nothing it can see guides it across that blank water, yet year after year it reliably turns up at the particular feeding and calving grounds it was heading for. The name of the device can wait. The whale is already using it.

The monarch: a program no individual could have learned

"And We have placed within the heaven great stars, and made it beautiful for those who behold it." (Quran 15:16)

"There is no creature on earth, nor a bird that flies with its wings, but they are communities like you. We have neglected nothing in the Record. Then to their Lord they will be gathered." (Quran 6:38)

Of all the travellers, though, the one I find most startling is the monarch butterfly.

Picture the destination first. High in the mountains of central Mexico stands a small cluster of oyamel fir groves, and you could fit the whole wintering ground onto a handful of hillsides. When autumn reaches eastern North America, monarchs aim for it from as far as three thousand miles away, and they hit not just the right region but the very same forests, one generation after another.

Steven Reppert and his colleagues have pieced together most of the steering, and it is exquisite. The monarch flies by the sun, and the sun will not hold still: it crosses roughly fifteen degrees of sky every hour. Keep a fixed angle to it and by evening you have flown a long curve. So the butterfly compensates, adjusting its angle as the hours pass with a circadian clock, and that clock lives in a surprising place. Part of it sits in the brain, but part sits in the antennae. Take the antennae away, or paint them over, and the butterfly still flies, but its compass no longer holds. For days when the sun is hidden it carries a second instrument, a light-dependent magnetic compass that reads the inclination of the earth's field.

Now for the part that makes your head spin. Not one of the butterflies reaching Mexico in autumn has been there before. The journey north in spring is a relay of three or four short-lived generations, each breeding and dying on the way. Then comes a special autumn generation, sometimes called the Methuselah generation, and it flies the whole route south in one go. Where its parents lived a few weeks, it lives eight or nine months. The secret is reproductive diapause. It puts the growth of its reproductive organs on hold and spends that energy on fat and survival instead.

At the centre of the switch is one hormone, helped along by insulin signalling and a handful of neuropeptides. Juvenile hormone is what normally pushes the insect to mature and breed. As the days shorten and the air cools, its level is held down, and that single change rewrites the whole life plan. No eggs. No courtship. Fat stored instead, and a lifespan stretched about tenfold. The return leg runs on the same hormone. After months in the Mexican mountains, the cold there releases the brake, the hormone climbs again, and the butterfly that went south as a celibate traveller heads north ready to breed. A single chemical dial, eased down for autumn and back up for spring, stretches a six-week insect into a nine-month one and then hands it back to ordinary life.

Not a single butterfly flies the round trip. None is shown the way. Yet the destination never wanders.

So where does the route live? In the genes. That is the beauty of it: the whole navigational program is innate, riding in the germline and handed on at conception with no lesson required, and once the program exists natural selection can tinker with its variations. The question that matters, then, is not how the information gets passed down. It is where it came from in the first place.

Write out the specification and it runs long. First the instruments: a sun compass, a clock tucked into the antennae that keeps adjusting it as the sun slides fifteen degrees an hour across the sky, and a magnetic inclination compass in reserve for overcast days. Then the itinerary, a heading to hold and a calendar tied to the season and the length of the day. Then the physiology, a developmental switch that suspends reproduction so one generation can outlive its parents tenfold. Last comes the return ticket. A spring reset, tripped by the cold of the wintering grounds, turns the descendants toward home rather than letting them carry on south.

Put together, that is a great deal of specific instruction, every piece functional and fitted to the others. And it has to come out largely right, because a relay across generations gives no chance to fix errors on the way. A bird that gets lost one season can do better the next. A monarch cannot. The butterfly that errs is never the one who would profit from the correction, and the generation that might have learned the lesson is gone before it could use it.

The obvious reply is that migratory programs change, and they can change fast. Take the blackcap. In the 1960s a few of these birds, which would ordinarily have spent the winter around the Mediterranean, began flying northwest to Britain instead. A few decades on, the British route was firmly in place and its birds had become a population of their own, measurably drifting from the stock they came from. The monarch's family history points the same way. Genomic studies put the North American migrants inside a widespread species whose members mostly never migrate, so this migration has come, gone and come back across the group instead of running unbroken from the beginning.

Look at what each of those cases actually is, though: a revision. A bearing swung. A timetable slid. A route was dropped and later resumed. Each change needs a migrant already in working order: before a blackcap can re-aim at Britain it must already own the clock, the compass, the physiology to fuel a long flight and the developmental switch that makes it a migrant at the right season. Any editor will tell you that tightening a manuscript is a smaller job than writing one, and nobody takes a good edit as proof that the book wrote itself. If anything, the case gets stronger. A program pliable enough to be pointed somewhere new within thirty years, and sturdy enough to be shut off and restarted across a genus, is a more impressive piece of engineering than any rigid one could be.

Which brings us back to the question this book began with, the origin of information, now in one of its sharpest forms. Here is a detailed, working set of instructions aimed at a goal that no butterfly carrying them out could ever have discovered for itself. Instructions like that trace back to a mind. Genetic instinct sits comfortably with that conclusion, which rests on one plain observation: specified, functional information on this scale has no demonstrated source other than intelligence.

Each autumn's flight is a message written in genetic code and carried out by a creature that has no idea what it says. The butterfly cannot read the instructions. It can only run them.

What the journeys have in common

Set the three journeys side by side. Give a young songbird any sky at all and it will make a star compass out of it. Behind it stand two magnetic senses, a quantum one in the eye and a magnetite one in the beak, and the magnetic signal is read by Cluster N, a forebrain region that wakes only for night migration. The whale crosses an ocean with nothing in view, guided by an inner compass whose workings we are still uncovering. And the monarch, over four generations, follows a sun-reading program kept true by a clock, all the way to a stand of firs that not one of them has visited before. Not bad for a songbird the weight of a few coins and an insect lighter than a paperclip.

Different animals and different physics, and all of them point the same way: toward systems packed with specific, purposeful information, the sensor matched to its reader and the program to its purpose. Instruments that cover for one another. A detector that is no compass without its reader, and comes with one. A rule that builds a compass out of the sky. A chemical dial that turns a six-week insect into a nine-month traveller. The design view accounts for where all of this came from, and the unguided view does not.

So go back out under the night sky. The stars that steer the bunting are the stars the verse points to: "We have detailed the signs for a people who know."

References

  • Quran 6:97, 15:16, 6:38.
  • Emlen, S. T. (1967, The Auk; 1970, Science 170, 1198–1201) — planetarium orientation experiments with indigo buntings; juveniles learn the sky's centre of rotation, and the Betelgeuse-rearing experiment shows that the inherited element is the rule ("orient by the point of rotation"), not a fixed star map.
  • Axial precession period ≈25,772 years; Thuban (α Draconis) lay within ~0.1° of the pole c. 2787 BC and served as pole star c. 3000–2500 BC, through the pyramid era; drift since then ~64°.
  • Mouritsen, H., & Hore, P. J. (2021), Nature 594 — cryptochrome radical-pair magnetic compass.
  • Xu et al. (2021), Nature 594 — cryptochrome 4 as the candidate magnetic sensor; the radical-pair model is the leading hypothesis.
  • Magnetite-based magnetoreception via the ophthalmic branch of the trigeminal nerve — evidence for a second, intensity-sensing ("map") magnetic system distinct from the radical-pair compass.
  • Cluster N: Mouritsen et al. (2005, PNAS); Heyers et al. (2007); Zapka et al. (2009, Nature 461) — forebrain region in night-migratory songbirds, active during nocturnal migratory behaviour; inactivation abolishes magnetic-compass orientation while sparing the sun and star compasses.
  • SOFAR (deep sound) channel — sound-speed minimum layer permitting long-range low-frequency propagation; relevant to cetacean acoustics; navigational use by whales remains a hypothesis.
  • Reppert, S. M., Merlin, C., et al. (2009), Science 325 — antennal circadian clocks and the time-compensated sun compass (sun moves ~15° per hour). Guerra, P. A., et al. (2014), Nature Communications 5 — light-dependent magnetic inclination compass in monarchs.
  • Monarch multigenerational migration; the long-lived autumn ("Methuselah") generation persists via reproductive diapause, mediated by suppression of juvenile hormone (corpora allata) under short photoperiod and low temperature, with insulin signalling and neuropeptides participating (Herman 1981; Denlinger 2002); cold exposure at the overwintering site releases the suppression and restores reproductive competence for the northward leg. Overwintering in the oyamel fir forests of Michoacán at ~3,000 m.
  • Pulido & Berthold (2010), PNAS — rapid evolution of blackcap migratory direction.
  • Zhan et al. (2014), Nature 514 — North American monarchs placed within a largely non-migratory species.
  • Meyer, Signature in the Cell — the origin-of-specified-information argument.

Download the whole book (free PDF)