No Design · The chapters

Chapter 8: Signs in the Sea

By the How To Muslim team

"And it is He who subjected the sea, that you may eat from it tender meat and extract from it ornaments you wear. And you see the ships plowing through it, that you may seek of His bounty, and that you may be grateful." (Quran 16:14)

Our species can show you a detailed map of Mars. Ask for an equally good map of our own seabed and there is an awkward pause, because the floor of the ocean has been charted in less detail than the surface of a planet we have never set foot on. A little embarrassing, when that ocean covers more than seventy percent of the world we actually live on. Beneath it waits a place so immense and so crowded with living things that going down into it feels like crossing a border into a country nobody has finished exploring.

Again and again the Quran brings us back to the sea, and it hands the sea over as a present rather than a barrier. Supper, in the form of tender meat. Jewellery, in pearls and coral. A road for the ships that knit one civilisation to the next. And above all a sign, left out for anyone who will stop and look long enough to feel grateful.

So let us stop and look. Down there you will meet an animal that fertilises an ocean, a reef that grows rich in empty water, a weapon that fires at the edge of what matter allows, an eye built to blur, and a brain that sleeps in shifts.

The whale pump: one species, one ocean

"Do you not see that Allah has subjected to you whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth, and lavished on you His blessings, seen and unseen?" (Quran 31:20)

The whale goes first, since it would be rude to keep something that size waiting. A breaching humpback flings forty tonnes of itself into the air and lets the lot fall back in a white burst of spray, and somehow it manages to look graceful doing it. Then there is the blue whale, which is larger again. Of every animal known to have lived on Earth, dinosaurs included, none has outgrown it.

Spectacle is the least of it, though. The whale's real talent is for working a very long lever. It reworks the chemistry of an ocean, and it never sets out to do anything grander than lunch.

A whale's routine has two parts. Down to the depths to eat, then back up to breathe and to empty its bowels. That second errand is the one that changes the ocean. Iron and nitrogen collected far below get released at the surface, in the sunlit water where they are scarcest, and Joe Roman, a marine biologist, named the process the whale pump. Phytoplankton feast on the delivery. These microscopic plants sit at the base of the entire marine food web; they make much of the oxygen on Earth and pull carbon dioxide from the air as they grow. Their bloom is grazed by krill, and the krill are eaten by fish, which are eaten by larger fish, and at the far end of that chain stand whole fisheries and the coastal economies that live off them. It is hard to name a humbler act with a longer reach.

Put a figure on it and the scale becomes hard to believe. Roman and McCarthy measured the nitrogen that marine mammals lift into the sunlit surface of the Gulf of Maine, and it comes to around twenty-three thousand tonnes a year. Every river that flows into the gulf, added together, delivers less. The whales on their own manage roughly double the rivers' entire supply. So a population of animals is outperforming the drainage of a continent, and all it does to achieve this is live. In the course of an ordinary day a whale feeds the sea and helps to keep the climate steady, and a great deal of life leans on that routine without knowing it. Chapter 6 found the same thing on the reef with the cleaner wrasse: remove a part that seemed incidental, and everything stacked on top of it begins to sag.

Whales are sociable on a grand scale, too. Male humpbacks sing for hours, and the song carries for miles. Each region has its own dialect, the dialects shift measurably from one year to the next, and now and then a new version sweeps through a whole ocean's population. Humpbacks, in other words, have hit songs, and the charts keep turning over. Sperm whales are matriarchal: the families rear their calves together and stay bonded for decades. Orca pods each keep a culture of their own, one group hunting this prey and another that, by techniques the old pass down to the young. Call it instinct if you like, but it looks a great deal more like society.

And whales are still schooling our engineers. Along the leading edge of a humpback's flipper runs a row of bumps called tubercles. The biologist Frank Fish mounted a real flipper in a wind tunnel and watched what the bumps do: they break the passing air into controlled vortices, and so the fin resists stalling and slips through with less drag. The numbers are not subtle. The flipper holds off stall until an angle about forty percent steeper and sheds up to a third of its drag; lift itself rises a few percent, and at some angles the ratio of lift to drag improves by close to a fifth. The principle now shapes turbine blades and industrial fans. That makes four times in this book that our engineers have arrived second: the bird's wing in Chapter 1, the chameleon's crystals in Chapter 3, the gecko's foot in Chapter 5, and now the humpback's flipper. Find a solution already built once and you have a curiosity. Find it again and again, and you have a fact about the world that asks to be explained.

The walking whales: a rebuild against the clock

The whale's own history is written in stone, and written clearly: its move from land to sea is one of the best-documented sequences in the entire fossil record. Hans Thewissen and others have laid out a graded series: Pakicetus, wolf-sized and living on land; Ambulocetus, shaped like a crocodile and web-footed; Rodhocetus, mostly at home in the water; and Basilosaurus, fully marine and still carrying tiny hind legs that were no use for walking, though perhaps still of use in mating. What the bones record is a rebuild on a staggering scale, carried out against the clock.

The full calculation lives in Chapter 3; the outline is enough here. To make a whale out of a land mammal you have to rebuild nearly everything at once. A blowhole appears and the skull is remodelled. Birth moves underwater and comes tail first. Nursing has to work in seawater. Then add a fluke, a layer of blubber, and a diving physiology able to cope with crushing pressure. Think of refitting a ship from keel to mast without once bringing it into dock. Count up the specific genetic changes, every one cooperating with the rest, that such an overhaul needs, and weigh them against what large mammals have to work with: slow generations, modest populations, and roughly eight million years, the window the fossils allow. The sums hit the waiting-time wall head on. So stone and sum tell one story. The stones say the rebuild happened; the sums put a very hard question to any unguided process that claims to have run it at that pace.

Dennis Venema gives the sharpest reply, and he leaves the sums alone to go after what they count. A waiting-time estimate assumes evolution had to find one particular set of mutations; Venema points out that a body plan can usually be reached by several genetic roads, that selection can work with variation a population already carries, and that the stages along the way may have paid their way for reasons that had nothing to do with becoming a whale.

Grant every one of those extra roads. None of them touches the real difficulty, which is coordination. A blowhole with no reflex to seal it on the way down is just a hole in the head. Milk has to be thick enough not to scatter in seawater, and the calf has to latch on without breathing in the ocean. A tail-first birth needs the physiology to see it through. Take any genetic route you like: every one of these pieces still had to turn up, fitted to the others and working, within those eight million years. So the burden sits squarely with the mechanism. Whatever claims the credit owes us an account of how it got all of that done in the time. The demand rests on coordination alone. It needs no impossibility proof, and no defended count of what had to be found and how many ways there were to find it. The fossils, then, are the case's best witness. They measure how much had to be rebuilt, and how short the clock was.

The reef: a city built in a desert

The great cities of the sea are its coral reefs, and their builders are about the size of a grain of rice. Each coral polyp lays down a skeleton of calcium carbonate. Leave enough of them at it for centuries and the skeletons stack into walls honeycombed with caves, arches and corridors, until you get Australia's Great Barrier Reef, which is visible from orbit. All this occupies remarkably little room. By area, reefs take up well under one percent of the ocean floor, nearer a tenth of one percent, and yet roughly a quarter of all marine species rely on them at some point in their lives. That is a lot of residents for so small a city. Young fish grow up in their nurseries, moray eels wait in the cracks, clownfish settle among the anemones. The reefs also blunt incoming storm waves, and that service comes with a price tag. Without the world's reefs, the yearly global cost of flood damage would roughly double. At present they prevent something over four billion dollars of it every year, and the reefs of the United States alone account for more than a billion and a half.

Behind a good share of that abundance is a lodger. Living inside the tissues of reef-building corals are microscopic algae known as zooxanthellae, and they pay their rent in food. By photosynthesis they make energy-rich compounds and hand them to their host, meeting up to ninety percent of what a shallow-water coral eats. The coral, for its part, gives them a sheltered home and the raw materials they need. Landlord and tenant both do very nicely out of the arrangement.

A reef also holds a puzzle that Darwin spotted on the voyage of the Beagle, and it still goes by his name: Darwin's paradox. Measured by nutrients, the tropical seas where reefs thrive are deserts. The blue water around a reef is notoriously empty, too starved of nourishment to support much of anything. And there, of all places, sit the richest and most varied ecosystems the sea possesses.

The answer is thrift. A reef hoards its nutrients and keeps them changing hands inside the system, losing so little that an enormous fortune in living things runs on almost no outside income. The coral and its alga sit at the centre of that economy. Whatever the alga produces by photosynthesis passes directly to its host; whatever the host discards passes directly back to feed the alga; and very little ever leaks out into the blue. One animal and one alga, from two different kingdoms, running a loop tight enough to put up a city in a desert.

So the real question a reef asks is about tuning. A nutrient budget this thin is paying for a city this rich, and the exchange at its centre has to be balanced finely enough for those books to close at all. A balance like that is what calibration looks like, and calibration is the work of a careful hand.

The nematocyst: at the edge of what matter allows

"And We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe?" (Quran 21:30)

At first sight the jellyfish looks like a lost plastic bag with ambitions. Look again and it becomes one of the most rewarding animals in the water. Its group, the cnidarians, has been adrift in the oceans for something like five hundred million years. Dinosaurs arrived and vanished in that time, and continents shuffled across the globe. The jellyfish saw it all without a brain, a heart, a single bone or a drop of blood. It gets by very well on what it has. It senses light and chemistry, it swims by pulsing its bell, and it sends nutrients through a network of branching canals that has no central pump to drive it.

Along its tentacles it carries a weapon that ranks among the most astonishing anywhere in biology. The nematocyst is a stinging capsule with a coiled thread inside, and it fires the instant something touches it. Its numbers press against the limits of what matter can do. Thomas Holstein and his colleagues filmed the discharge at more than a million frames a second and timed it at around seven hundred billionths of a second. The acceleration runs to some five million times gravity. At the point of impact, the local pressure is in the range of a bullet strike.

All the work is done beforehand, by osmosis. The molecules crammed inside the capsule pull it up to a pressure on the order of a hundred and fifty atmospheres, swelling it by about a third as it loads, and the wall holds that energy in a material that bears comparison with spider silk. Then there is the weight. The entire capsule comes to about a nanogram, which explains the rest of those outrageous accelerations: there is hardly anything to get moving. Firing is just a matter of the trigger unlatching the door. A cocked spring lets go in a fraction of a microsecond, with no muscle, pump or nerve anywhere in the chain.

The whale made its case through parts that are useless without each other. The nematocyst makes it through sheer performance: speeds and pressures out at the boundary of what physics permits, reached by an animal with no brain, inside a structure only a few micrometres wide, and produced by the thousand on every tentacle. It is precision engineering, and the jellyfish runs it as an assembly line.

The box jellyfish: an eye deliberately blurred

The box jellyfish has no brain and twenty-four eyes. They come in four clusters, called rhopalia, set at intervals around its bell. When Dan-Eric Nilsson and his colleagues examined them, they found that some are true lensed eyes capable of forming images. Each has a retina, and a lens whose refractive index shifts gradually between its centre and its edge. That gradient corrects the smearing an ordinary lens produces around its rim, and the result is optics very nearly free of aberration, the very quality human lens makers work so hard for. Finding such an eye on an animal with no central brain to look at the picture would be wonder enough. What the jellyfish actually does with it is stranger.

It throws the focus away. The lens is fully able to form a sharp image, but its focal point falls behind the light-sensitive cells, so what reaches the retina is soft by design. For a while that looked like an error. Then researchers asked the obvious question: what does this animal need to see? The answer is mangroves. A box jellyfish finds its way by big, unmoving landmarks, the canopy overhead, glimpsed through the surface. From underwater the whole world above is squeezed into a bright circular window about a hundred degrees across, and blurring wipes out the fine print while keeping precisely the broad shapes the jellyfish steers by. Give a brainless animal a sharp image and you bury it in information it has no means to process. So the lens does the editing, passing on what the animal can use and quietly discarding everything else. A filter, ground into the eye itself.

The polar bear taught us this in Chapter 3. Left to ourselves, we would have marked the blurry eye down as a botched job, because surely a lens exists to focus. Look closer and it turns out to be fitted to a need we never thought to ask about. For an eye, best means fit for the job, not sharpest possible, and deciding what fits a job is a judgement about purpose, the very kind a designer makes.

Sleep at sea: the same answer, found twice

"And among His signs is your sleep by night and day, and your seeking of His bounty. Surely in that are signs for people who listen." (Quran 30:23)

Sleep is one of the body's non-negotiables, as anyone who has tried negotiating with it at three in the morning can confirm. It is when cells get repaired and memories consolidated, and it keeps immunity and metabolism in order. Skimp on it and the bill comes due: thinking falters and the defences weaken, with chronic illness waiting further down the road. That raises a hard question for life in the water. How does an animal that must keep moving, or keep breathing, ever afford to switch off?

The neatest solution in the sea belongs to the dolphin. Every breath it takes is a decision: it has to choose to go up for air, and that means it can never let itself go completely under. Full unconsciousness would drown it. Oleg Lyamin and Jerome Siegel, who study sleep, have recorded how it gets round the problem. One half of the dolphin's brain sleeps, and the eye on the opposite side closes, while the other half stays on duty, swimming, surfacing and keeping a lookout. After a while the halves swap. Half a dolphin is always awake, which is more than most of us can claim before breakfast.

Here is the telling part. Plenty of birds sleep the same way. One hemisphere rests while the open eye scans for predators, and a bird roosting on the outside of a flock will reliably keep open the eye that faces outward, away from the flock. Consider how far apart a dolphin and a duck stand on the tree of life. They share a problem, needing rest without ever going fully dark, and they share an answer that is neither simple nor obvious: divide the brain and let it work in shifts.

We have been here before. In Chapter 1 it was echolocation, worked out by bats and by dolphins alike, and there the word convergence turned out to describe the pattern without accounting for it. Sleeping in shifts sends us down the same road. Lineages this remote keep landing on the same well-matched, unlikely answer. Coincidence is a fine explanation once. By the second time it starts to look like a habit, and the plainer reading is that the answers were waiting to be found because something had laid them out in advance.

Our own sleep is arranged with no less care. Breathing carries on while the mind is elsewhere. Through the night we turn and resettle, sparing our tissues the pressure of lying still, and never wake to do it. Every single night we sink into deep unconsciousness and surface again into full alertness, unharmed, and nobody ever sat us down to teach us how.

And the organ presiding over all of this is lavishly expensive. The human brain makes up about two percent of the body's mass and consumes something like a fifth of its energy. Chapter 3 argued that the human mind carries a surplus far beyond what survival needs, and this running cost makes the point sharper. An organ that hungry ought to earn its keep in survival terms, yet a large share of its output (mathematics, music, cosmology) was never on the invoice.

What the sea comes to

Look back over the dive. A single species keeps an ocean's chemistry turning. A bumpy flipper puts our engineers in second place for the fourth time in this book. The fossil whales give Chapter 3's arithmetic a deadline: every rebuilt system had to arrive in working order beside the others before the clock ran out. A reef answers Darwin's paradox with a closed loop tuned finely enough to raise the richest ecosystems on Earth in the barest water on Earth. And then the small marvels: a capsule with no muscle and no nerve firing at the edge of what physics allows, an eye that blurs on purpose, and a dolphin and a duck, strangers on the tree of life, resting by the same unlikely trick.

Different corners of the sea, one verdict. From the nanogram capsule on a jellyfish's tentacle to the forty-tonne whale breaking the surface, the same careful hand is at work at every scale.

The verse says the sea was made subject to us: for our food, our adornment, our travel and our wonder. It also names the response that fits. Eat from it, wear what it yields, watch the ships plough through it, and then do what the verse asks of you. Be grateful.

References

  • Quran 16:14, 31:20, 21:30, 30:23 — the verses quoted in this chapter.
  • Roman, J., & McCarthy, J. J. (2010). "The Whale Pump: Marine Mammals Enhance Primary Productivity in a Coastal Basin." PLoS ONE 5 — marine mammals return ~2.3 × 10⁴ tonnes of nitrogen a year to the Gulf of Maine euphotic zone, more than all riverine input to the gulf combined; cetaceans 14 × 10⁸ mol N/yr and pinnipeds 2.5, against 8 for all rivers.
  • Fish, F. E., et al. (2001, 2011) — humpback leading-edge tubercles as passive vortex generators; wind-tunnel results: stall angle delayed ~40%, drag reduced up to ~32%, maximum lift coefficient up ~6% (0.88→0.93), lift-to-drag ratio up ~17.6% at 10° angle of attack.
  • Thewissen, J. G. M., et al. — the whale-transition fossil series (Pakicetus, Ambulocetus, Rodhocetus, Basilosaurus); the land-to-marine window of eight million years, as in Thewissen's The Walking Whales: From Land to Water in Eight Million Years.
  • Sternberg, R., & Discovery Institute, Living Waters (2015) — the population-genetics waiting-time argument applied to the land-to-whale transition.
  • Venema, D. (BioLogos) — reply to the waiting-time argument: multiple genetic routes, standing variation, and intermediates useful for other reasons relax the requirement that one specified set of mutations be found.
  • Coral–zooxanthellae symbiosis — shallow-water corals derive up to ~90% of their energy from their algae.
  • Darwin's paradox — the high productivity and diversity of coral reefs in nutrient-poor tropical waters, noted by Darwin during the Beagle voyage and resolved by tight internal nutrient recycling.
  • Muscatine, L., & Porter, J. W. (1977) — the canonical account of tight internal nutrient recycling on reefs: zooxanthellae translocate up to ~90% of fixed carbon to the host, which returns ammonium, phosphate and CO₂.
  • Reef area and value: ~284,300 km², roughly 0.1% of the ocean surface, supporting ~25% of marine species. Flood protection: Beck et al. (2018, Nature Communications), global flood damages roughly double without reefs, >$4bn/yr averted; Reguero et al., US reefs >$1.8bn/yr.
  • Holstein, T., Nüchter, T., et al. (2006). "Nanosecond-scale kinetics of nematocyst discharge." Current Biology 16 — ~700 ns discharge, ~5.41 million g, local pressures >7 GPa, filmed at ~1.43 million frames per second; driven by a pre-stressed molecular spring.
  • Nematocyst energetics — intracapsular osmotic pressure ~15 MPa (~150 atmospheres) stored before discharge; capsule swelling ~30% before firing; capsule mass ~1 ng.
  • Nilsson, D.-E., et al. (2005). "Advanced optics in a jellyfish eye." Nature 435 — lensed, image-forming eyes in the box jellyfish with a graded-index lens nearly free of spherical aberration; under-focused, filtering fine detail while preserving navigational landmarks such as the mangrove canopy seen through Snell's window, the ~100° cone through which the world above the surface is visible from below.
  • Lyamin, O., & Siegel, J. — unihemispheric slow-wave sleep in dolphins; also documented in birds.
  • Rattenborg, N. C., et al. (2000) — unihemispheric sleep and unilateral eye closure in birds at the edge of a group.
  • Human brain energy budget (~20% of resting metabolism, ~2% of body mass) — standard physiology; connects to the argument from the surplus of the mind in Chapter 3.

Download the whole book (free PDF)