No Design · The chapters

Chapter 9: Signs in Yourself

By the How To Muslim team

"Indeed, We created man from a drop of mingled fluids, in order to test him; so We made him hearing and seeing." (Quran 76:2)

Set aside, for a moment, the question of who you are. Ask what you are.

Start with the count. Roughly thirty-seven trillion cells make up the creature reading this sentence, each one a chemical factory with its own production lines, and together they behave as a single body, coordinated so intricately that no computer yet built can simulate the whole. The verse above traces all of it to a drop of mingled fluids. That is a modest return address for engineering you could spend a lifetime exploring.

The Quran often points us inward and offers the body itself as evidence. This chapter takes it at its word, following you through a night's sleep, into the ear, the heart and the lungs, up into the brain and the odd fact that any of it is felt, and back to the womb where it started. We start tonight, the moment you fall asleep.

Sleep: an expensive habit

"And of His signs is your sleep by night and day, and your seeking of His bounty. Surely in that are signs for people who listen." (Quran 30:23)

Each night you surrender to unconsciousness for hours, and your brain treats the occasion as a work shift. It files the day's memories, clears away connections it no longer needs, and washes itself. The neuroscientist Maiken Nedergaard discovered the network that does the washing and named it the glymphatic system; among the waste it carries off are the proteins whose buildup is linked to Alzheimer's. On her account, the night-time timing comes down to plumbing. As you fall asleep the spaces between brain cells open by something like sixty percent, and fluid that could barely creep through the crowded tissue of a waking brain now flows through it freely. Night is when the brain unlocks its doors for the cleaners.

What sleep demands of an animal is beyond argument, whatever the final verdict on the cleaning crew (a 2024 study reported the reverse pattern, with clearance dropping during sleep and anaesthesia). It arrives on schedule, every complex creature needs it, it costs a great deal of energy, and withholding it kills.

A night has an architecture of its own, swinging between two kinds of sleep. In the deep non-REM phases the body mends: growth hormone goes out, tissues are repaired, the immune system gathers its forces. In REM the eyes flicker beneath the lids, dreams turn vivid, and the brain turns to emotion and problem-solving. Skip a single night and your judgement slides to about where a legally drunk driver's would be. Keep skipping and the deprivation eventually proves fatal.

Now think about the price. For hours every day a sleeping animal lies senseless and unguarded, open to anything with teeth; an engineer designing purely for survival would strike the feature at the first meeting. Yet every creature with a complex nervous system sleeps, on a timetable matched to its age: teenagers need extra while their brains reorganise, and older people sleep more lightly as their melatonin falls away. The habit even runs deeper than brains. The upside-down jellyfish has none, nor anything you could fairly call a central nervous system, and still it settles into a sleep-like state; keep it from resting and it sleeps longer afterwards, paying off the debt just as you do after a bad night. Sleep was required of animals before they had anything to think with. Something this costly sits at the centre of the daily cycle, and the whole organism is organised around it.

That raises a practical puzzle. An animal that switches off its mind every night ought, by rights, to die of the habit. What keeps it alive until morning?

Two arrangements stand out. The first is your breathing, which was never placed under your management (a mercy, since you would make a hopeless night-shift supervisor). A small knot of brainstem cells called the pre-Bötzinger complex sets its rhythm whatever the conscious cortex is doing, so the diaphragm goes on rising and falling long after your mind has signed off. The second is the way you turn over. Pressure on the skin builds up faint signals, too weak to wake you but strong enough to make you shift. Without those shifts, tissue pressed against the mattress for hours loses its blood supply and begins to die, which is how pressure sores form in patients who can no longer make the small automatic adjustments. Sleep comes with its own night staff, whose only job is to hand you back alive in the morning.

Hearing: tuned to the floor of physics

Every sound you hear begins as a ripple of pressure in the air. The outer ear catches those ripples, and its folds help you judge where they came from. Behind the eardrum lies a difficulty: the inner ear is full of fluid, and fluid resists a push that air alone is too feeble to give. The fix is a chain of tiny bones, the hammer, the anvil and the stirrup, three of the smallest you own. Working as a lever, they gather the eardrum's faint, spread-out motion and deliver it at roughly twenty times the pressure. The fluid fills the cochlea, a coiled spiral lined with about fifteen thousand hair cells arranged like piano keys, each answering to its own pitch, and between them they turn motion into the electrical code your brain hears as thunder, a blackbird or a voice you love. Next door, three looped semicircular canals register every turn of your head and keep you upright.

Two of those bones have had a remarkable change of career. The hammer and anvil started out as part of the jaw joint in our reptile-like ancestors, a move recorded in fossils such as Morganucodon and Liaoconodon and still replayed by a newborn marsupial in the pouch. In their new trade they serve an instrument whose quality comes down to a single number.

The usual boast made on the ear's behalf involves a hydrogen atom: it can supposedly sense a movement that small. The real figure is better. Work by James Hudspeth and others shows the cochlea answering eardrum movements of less than a picometre, over a hundred times narrower than the atom in the boast. Physics sets a floor here, where the molecules of the medium are already jostling with heat, and below it there is no signal to find, only that thermal trembling. Your ear works close to that floor. It does more than receive, too: its outer hair cells serve as living amplifiers, which stretches your range from the faintest rustle to a jet engine and lets you pick out one voice in a noisy room, the cocktail party effect. Machines have got far better at that trick. They still lose to you, while drawing many orders of magnitude more power.

This is calibration at the limit, the same kind of evidence the camel's tolerances gave us in Chapter 3 and the matched charges of the proton and electron gave us in Chapter 5. Here is an instrument parked at the very edge of what physics allows. Whatever route its parts took to get there, a detector tuned to the floor of the physical world asks to be explained, and tuning is what designers do.

Circulation and breath: no scheduled downtime

"And indeed, in the grazing livestock is a lesson for you. We give you drink from what is in their bellies, between waste and blood, pure milk, pleasant for those who drink it." (Quran 16:66)

Consider the pipework. Your heart, a muscle about the size of your fist, beats around a hundred thousand times a day, something like two and a half billion times over a lifetime. Each beat drives blood into a network of vessels that modern recalculations put at ten to twenty thousand kilometres. Even that is millions of times the height of the person carrying it, threaded so finely that every cell sits within a few cell-widths of a supply line. In all those decades it never once closes for maintenance.

What travels through those pipes is a mixed crew. Red cells carry oxygen on haemoglobin and unload it precisely where it is needed. White cells patrol for invaders. Platelets can seal a wound within seconds. The pump keeps equally strict order: a natural pacemaker sends an electrical wave across the heart so its four chambers contract in sequence, while pressure sensors, hormones and nerves revise its output moment by moment. Climb the stairs and it speeds up; sit down and it settles. Nobody consults you.

The lungs are its equal. By the time a breath reaches them, your nose has already filtered, warmed and moistened it. Down the reinforced trachea it goes, dividing and dividing again through ever narrower branches until it ends in around three hundred million tiny sacs. Laid flat, they would cover seventy to a hundred and forty square metres, something like half a tennis court packed behind your ribs. Across their gossamer-thin walls oxygen drifts into the blood and carbon dioxide drifts out, moved by nothing but the difference in concentration on either side. No pump drives the exchange, and none is needed.

Now ask an engineer for the service schedule. Everything we manufacture is planned around the day it stops: the car goes into the garage, the servers go dark for a weekend. A machine that runs eighty years without a shutdown, matches its output to demand second by second, repairs its own parts while running and never sees a technician is a machine we have never built. Your heart and lungs get no downtime. They cannot afford any, and they were made so they would never need it.

Vestigial organs: a verdict that keeps being overturned

This is usually where someone raises the old counter-argument of vestigial organs. The appendix, the tailbone and the wisdom teeth get paraded as useless leftovers from our evolutionary past, parts no designer would have bothered to fit.

Biologists use "vestigial" for a structure reduced or repurposed from a fuller ancestral role, and real examples of that exist; a vestigial part can still do useful work. The verdict that keeps collapsing is a different one: "useless."

Take the appendix, which spent a hundred years in the textbooks' junk drawer. In 2007 a team at Duke University proposed that it serves as a safe house for friendly gut bacteria, restocking the intestine after an illness flushes it out, and the evidence has stood up since. It holds immune tissue as well. The tailbone, long filed as a leftover, anchors the pelvic floor muscles that make continence possible, which makes it a leftover most of us would miss within the hour. You have seen this plot before. The retina in the Introduction was mocked as wired backwards until its Müller cells turned out to be guiding light, and the polar bear of Chapter 3 wears fur that is not white.

What is really on trial, then, is a habit of reasoning. "I cannot see what this is for, so it is for nothing" has been retired, case after case, every time knowledge improved. Track records are how we judge a method, and this one has been judged. Treating our present ignorance as evidence against design is a move history has embarrassed over and over. The junk drawer keeps emptying.

The brain: the argument that holds

Inside your skull sit about eighty-six billion neurons, a figure we have because the neuroscientist Suzana Herculano-Houzel went to the trouble of counting them. They make something like a hundred trillion connections, a scaling estimate rather than a count, in the same range as the usual figures for the stars in our galaxy. The organ weighs about three pounds, two percent of your mass, yet takes around a fifth of your energy, and with it you see, remember, speak, make art, weigh right against wrong and know that you exist. Its regions specialise and still act as one, sending signals along nerves at up to around 120 metres per second. It rewires itself for as long as you live, and after an injury it can sometimes move a lost function into another region.

Our nearest rival is a long way behind. Training the large artificial-intelligence models of recent years swallows a significant and growing share of the world's electricity, and the finished product still cannot do what your brain manages on about twenty watts. The dim bulb in your fridge draws more. An image model learns what a cat is from millions of labelled pictures. A toddler gets it from a few cats in passing, and can then tell a cat from a tiger, the distinction that matters most if you are planning to stroke one.

Two design arguments start here. The first is about information. The second is about you.

Random mutations, the argument runs, can shuffle or damage the instructions an organism already has, but they do not write genuinely new functional ones, and the brain's complexity outruns anything that process could assemble. Stephen Meyer has built this case at length, drawing on the protein-space mathematics of the Introduction. Mainstream biology contests it with a ready answer: a duplicated gene can diverge until it does something new. Much of the quarrel turns on what ought to count as "new information," and that answer has now been put to the test.

The classic form of the answer is Ohno's: with two copies of a gene, one keeps the old job while the spare is free to drift into a new one. In the laboratory the spare copy did come under relaxed selection, just as predicted. Then it mostly fell apart. Freed from duty, the copies tended to decay like a spare tyre left out in the weather, and losing function proved a far likelier outcome than gaining one. Biologists call this Ohno's dilemma. Duplication has produced new functions in documented cases, the antifreeze proteins of polar fish among them, so the live dispute is about numbers: how often the route succeeds and how far it can reach. On the direct test, decay won by a wide margin.

The second argument stands on firmer ground, and to my mind it is the strongest single point in this chapter.

Imagine neuroscience finished. Every neuron charted, every connection traced, every pattern of firing recorded and matched without error to everything the person reports feeling. One question would be left exactly where it started: why should any of that activity be felt? Ions cross a membrane, and somewhere there is the redness of red, or the ache of grief. It could all have gone on in the dark. Describe a system completely in physical terms and you have described what it does. Whether there is something it is like to be that system is a question the description never reaches.

The philosopher David Chalmers gave this its name, the hard problem of consciousness, and it is still unsolved. The shape of the gap matters. Ordinary ignorance shrinks as data comes in: build a better scanner and a missing circuit turns up. This gap behaves differently. Pile on more wiring detail and you are still answering some other question, because what needs explaining is how physical facts give rise to experience at all. A hole of that kind is a different creature from a blank awaiting the next experiment, and it sits very uncomfortably beside the confident claim that a human being is unguided matter and nothing more.

Pain: the flaw that turns out to be mercy

"Every soul will taste death. And We test you with evil and good as a trial, and to Us you will be returned." (Quran 21:35)

No one has ever wished for more pain, and few things protect us better. Touch a hot pan and heat-sensitive nerve endings fire while your skin is still intact; your hand is off the handle before you know why. The system has layers. The body's own opioids turn the signal up or down, and the messages come in different dialects: a sharp stab for harm happening now, a dull ache for trouble that is staying, and referred pain, felt in one place while pointing to a hidden organ elsewhere.

If you doubt its value, look at the people born without it. Congenital insensitivity to pain comes from rare mutations, and those who have it injure themselves without ever knowing. They chew their own tongues. They walk around on broken bones. They scald themselves and feel nothing. Many die young. A life free of pain sounds like a blessing until you see one lived, and then it looks like walking through the world blindfolded.

We have been here before. At first sight pain looks like the clearest case against a benevolent Creator, a cruelty wired into the body, which is exactly why it is so often pressed into service against one. Look closer and it is a guardian whose absence is a catastrophe. Add it to the collection, beside the polar bear's coat, the retina, the appendix and the box jellyfish's blurred eye. Each time we decided how a body ought to have been built, closer study overturned the verdict, and it always fell the same way.

Protection comes in humbler shapes too, and few are humbler than the sphincters, which rarely make it into poetry. These rings of muscle act as gates: one keeps stomach acid out of your throat, another sizes your pupil to the light, others hold back waste until the moment suits you. The clever part is the double arrangement. The inner ones run on their own while the outer ones take your orders, so you are spared the job of managing your own plumbing and still get the final say on timing. Without that partnership there would be no long meetings, no shared meals, no wedding feast. Polite society rests, quite literally, on this unglamorous engineering.

Development: a program on a schedule

"And certainly did We create man from an extract of clay. Then We placed him as a drop in a firm lodging. Then We made the drop into a clinging clot, and the clot into a lump, and We made the lump into bones, and clothed the bones with flesh; then We produced him as another creation. So blessed is Allah, the best of creators." (Quran 23:12-14)

You started as one cell, and nature has few processes more intricate than what came next. That first cell, the zygote, already held the full genetic library: about twenty thousand protein-coding genes spread over twenty-three pairs of chromosomes. It split, and split again, shaped itself into a hollow ball and lodged in the womb. From there the body unfolded on a timetable. By around three weeks a heart was beating. Nerves made their connections by the billion. Limbs budded out, left matching right.

None of it happens by itself. Each stage waits on a particular set of genes being switched on together, at a particular time and in a particular place, and a single cue delivered too early or too late can throw the whole build off course. Still, the process usually runs to completion without a flaw, steered by instructions so compact that a pinhead of DNA could hold the plans for billions of people. Most of us cannot get one flat-pack bookcase assembled in the right order.

The kangaroo taught us this in Chapter 3. Impressive parts are only half the story; the real achievement is the timetable. Fill a factory with the finest machines in the world, start them in the wrong order, and all you will make is a mess.

The verse above traces the same journey in stages: a drop, a clinging form, a lump, then bones clothed with flesh. The imagery is vivid, and ʿalaqa, the word for the early embryo, carries the sense of something that clings, which suits implantation well. Reading it as an exact preview of modern embryology is contested, among Muslim scholars too: bone and muscle in fact develop side by side, and scripture tied too tightly to one decade's science is fragile. As with the cosmology verses in Chapter 4, the Quran presents creation as signs to reflect on, and that invitation does not depend on reading its verses as an embryology textbook. It points the reflective mind to the orderly unfolding of a human being from a drop, and to the only fitting response: "So blessed is Allah, the best of creators."

The embryo: instructions, not reminiscence

An old idea holds that a growing embryo replays its evolutionary history, passing through a fish stage complete with gills. Its poor reputation is well earned.

Ernst Haeckel did more than anyone to popularise it, with nineteenth-century drawings that made the embryos of different animals look far more alike than they really are. When the embryologist Michael Richardson compared those drawings with actual embryos in 1997, the distortions were plain: features dropped, likenesses inflated. Haeckel's own university censured him. The doctrine that ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny is discredited, and the folds in a human embryo's neck, once advertised as gill slits, go on to form parts of the jaw, the ear and the throat.

Vertebrate embryos converge on one conserved middle stage, the phylotypic stage, when they look more alike than they do earlier or later; researchers study it today under the name of the developmental hourglass. It is a shared waypoint, and the road through it runs one way.

Development looks forward. It runs a program written in a genetic code, building a human being step by step from instructions, with no sentimental tour of ancestral adult forms along the way.

Small precisions

"We will show them Our signs in the horizons and within themselves, until it becomes clear to them that it is the truth." (Quran 41:53)

Turn your hands over. The ridges on your fingertips belong to no one else, not even an identical twin, because each set was laid down in the womb under conditions that never repeat exactly: pressure, position, blood flow. They help you grip wet and slippery things. Their subtler job shows up when you slide a finger across something textured. The ridges vibrate, and their spacing pitches the vibration at about two hundred cycles a second, very close to the frequency the touch receptors beneath them respond to best. So your fingerprints translate texture into a signal tuned to the very sensor waiting to read it, which sharpens fine touch many times over. Your fingertips have been doing signal processing all along; you thought you were just touching things. The pattern lasts from cradle to grave, and after a burn or a cut it grows back the same, because the deeper skin structure that shapes it survives.

Then there is your tongue, which gets far less credit than it has earned. It is a muscular hydrostat, all muscle and no bone, and since muscle hardly compresses, its volume stays fixed: narrow it and it lengthens, shorten it and it thickens. Trading one dimension for another, a boneless organ reaches a precision nothing rigid could match. Its thousands of taste buds detect sweet, sour, salt, bitter and umami, and every part of it can taste all five with only slight differences in sensitivity (the school diagram of neat taste zones was a simplification).

Taste is the least of it. Alongside the lips, teeth, palate and vocal cords, it shapes hundreds of distinct sounds a minute without your ever thinking where it is. Say "thought" slowly and count the positions it passes through; you do that at conversational speed without a moment's attention. It also runs your swallowing, driving each mouthful back while the epiglottis closes over the airway, dozens of muscles firing in sequence with no command from you.

Shared code: the reuse of what works

The last common objection turns to DNA. Humans and chimpanzees, we are told, share about ninety-eight percent of their DNA, and code that similar across species is supposed to prove common ancestry.

The percentage depends on how you count. The familiar ninety-eight compares the genomes letter by letter, and only along stretches that line up neatly. Roy Britten and others argued that insertions and deletions of whole segments belong in the tally; count them and the figure drops into the mid-nineties (about ninety-five percent on Britten's reckoning), or lower on some analyses. Britten's method has critics of its own, who say insertion and deletion lengths vary too wildly to measure evolutionary distance at all. Either way, a number that moves with the ruler is a slippery thing to hang a verdict on.

The deeper issue is what likeness means. Two things built from the same code may be related by birth, or they may come from the same workshop. Programmers drop one tried and tested library into a whole family of products, and nobody concludes that the spreadsheet is descended from the word processor; the same team made both. On a design view, creatures sharing one world, one atmosphere and one biochemistry are just what you would expect to find assembled from many of the same parts. A protein that does a given job is bound to resemble others doing that job, whatever its origin.

Those who press the evolutionary case in earnest lean on something else, nested hierarchies: shared features falling into groups within groups, branches upon branches. The bare percentage, brought out as if it closed the question, closes nothing, because likeness by itself fits common descent and common design equally well. A world whose creatures breathe one air and run on one chemistry is precisely where a maker would reuse what works, and shared code is at home there.

The signs within

Step back now and take in the whole.

Pull on any thread and the rest of the body comes with it. Your brain sets the pace of your heart, and your heart keeps your brain supplied with oxygen. That oxygen arrives through your lungs, which fill only because your diaphragm moves, and your diaphragm moves on orders from that small cluster of brainstem cells, asleep or awake. The brainstem sits under the skull's protection, propped up by the spine and fuelled by the gut. Every system leans on several others. A heap of parts that merely happened to get along would look nothing like this.

Gather up what we have seen. An ear so finely tuned that it registers motions far smaller than an atom, down at the floor physics allows. A heart and a pair of lungs that work a whole lifetime without a day off. A developmental program that keeps time from a single cell to a newborn child. And all through the chapter, from the appendix to the experience of pain, our verdicts of "pointless" and "cruel" giving way under closer study.

At the centre of it all is an inner life that no physical account has explained. The hard problem marks the spot where a purely material account of a human being has, so far, nothing to say at all.

Again and again the Quran sends us to the signs within ourselves, and modern physiology has only made that call louder. You need no telescope to find this evidence and no archive to search for it. It beats in your chest, it thinks behind your eyes, it reads the world through your fingertips.

It is you.

References

  • Quran 76:2, 30:23, 16:66, 21:35, 23:12-14, 41:53 — the verses quoted in this chapter.
  • Xie, L., Nedergaard, M., et al. (2013), Science — the glymphatic system; interstitial space expands by ~60% during non-REM sleep, permitting convective flow of cerebrospinal fluid and clearance of amyloid-beta and tau, with amyloid-beta cleared ~2× faster.
  • Miao et al. (2024), Nature Neuroscience — brain clearance reported as reduced during sleep and anaesthesia; Smith et al. (2017, eLife) also challenged the convective mechanism.
  • Dawson & Reid (1997), Nature — 17 hours awake ≈ 0.05% blood alcohol; 24 hours ≈ 0.10%. Rechtschaffen's disk-over-water rats died in 11–32 days of sleep deprivation while yoked controls stayed healthy.
  • Cassiopea (upside-down jellyfish) — a sleep-like state with homeostatic rebound despite having no centralised nervous system.
  • Smith, J. C., et al. (1991), Science — identification of the pre-Bötzinger complex in the medulla as the respiratory rhythm generator, operating independently of cortical control and sustaining breathing during unconsciousness.
  • Nocturnal micro-arousals and pressure-driven postural shifts preventing ischaemic tissue damage — clinical basis of pressure-ulcer formation in immobile patients.
  • Hudspeth, A. J. — cochlear mechanotransduction; hair-bundle sensitivity to sub-picometre displacements, near the thermal-noise floor; outer hair cells as the "cochlear amplifier."
  • Mammalian middle-ear ossicles (malleus and incus) derive from ancestral jaw-joint bones (articular and quadrate) — Morganucodon (functioning double jaw joint), Liaoconodon (ossicles detached into the middle ear); marsupial neonates use the bones as jaw supports, and they migrate to the ear during pouch life.
  • Cardiovascular and respiratory figures — lifetime heartbeats ~2.5–2.6 billion; total blood-vessel length ~9,000–19,000 km on modern recalculations; alveolar gas-exchange surface 70–140 m² (a singles tennis court is 195.7 m²).
  • Bollinger, R. R., & Parker, W. (2007) — the appendix as a "safe house" for beneficial gut bacteria; "vestigial" in biology means reduced or repurposed from an ancestral role.
  • Herculano-Houzel, S. (2009) — ~86 billion neurons by direct count.
  • Synapse count ~10¹⁴ — a scaling estimate (neurons × ~1,000), not a measurement.
  • Human brain power draw ~20 W (~20% of resting metabolism at ~2% of body mass), against megawatt-scale demand for large AI training clusters.
  • Meyer, S. C., Signature in the Cell — the argument that mutations do not generate new functional information, a contested design contention; gene duplication and divergence is the standard counter.
  • Ohno's dilemma — a direct experimental test of the duplication-and-divergence model confirmed relaxed selection on redundant copies but found loss of function far more common than new function; documented cases of new function by duplication (e.g. antifreeze proteins) exist.
  • Chalmers, D. (1995). "Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness" — the hard problem.
  • Congenital insensitivity to pain (SCN9A loss-of-function) — standard clinical genetics.
  • Richardson, M. K., et al. (1997), Anatomy and Embryology — Haeckel's drawings compared with real embryos and shown to be inaccurate; recapitulation is discredited, while the conserved phylotypic stage (the "developmental hourglass") is real.
  • Scheibert, J., et al. (2009), Science — fingerprint ridge spacing converts sliding contact into vibrations near ~200 Hz, matching the peak sensitivity of subdermal Pacinian corpuscles and greatly amplifying fine-texture discrimination.
  • Kier, W. M., & Smith, K. K. (1985) — muscular hydrostats; constant volume means contraction in one axis forces extension in another.
  • Britten, R. J. (2002), PNAS — human–chimpanzee divergence of ~5% when insertions and deletions are counted, so the ~98% figure is method-dependent; critics of the method argue that indel-length distributions cannot serve as a divergence measure.

Download the whole book (free PDF)